Onslaught was the first set that I really collected cards out of, and I was enamored with the tribal 'lord' cycle that let you tap five creatures sharing a creature type to do something crazy. The first deck I built that made people genuinely upset at me was one that involved Supreme Inquisitor and Riptide Chronologist. It's certainly not an efficient interaction, but when everyone is trying to cast 8 drops, it's a totally serviceable plan.
When that got old, I built decks around Catapult Master, and then Ancestor's Prophet. Locking people out of creatures and killing people with Doubtless One plus Starlit Sanctum were both a ton of fun. But I never really got to go off with my favorite Lord. Gravespawn Sovereign is the one that always seemed the most exciting, but there's a bunch of problems with getting it off the ground.
- What exactly are you reanimating? If you're killing a bunch of things and then reanimating them, how exactly are you getting to five zombies on the battlefield?
- If you're stocking your own graveyard, why are you playing Gravespawn Sovereign and not just Zombify or some such?
Things are very different in 2019. I first started exploring this card again a number of years ago when Sidisi, Brood Tyrant was printed. I combined Sidisi with a bunch of dredge creatures so that you could tear through your library, make a bunch of zombies, and cast some Spider Spawnings. At some point you could resolve Gravespawn Sovereign, get a couple activations out of it, and take over the board out of nowhere. I gave up on Sidisi because the deck was a little too volatile for my tastes. If you milled the cards you wanted to draw and drew the cards you wanted to mill, your deck just didn't do anything.
I started experimenting again with Gisa and Geralf when Eldritch Moon came out. This card guarantees that you consistently have a bunch of zombies in play and means that you generally don't care which cards get milled over. In my experience, the best way to make a billion zombie tokens in this type of deck is Noosegraf Mob. The cool thing about Noosegraf Mob? It creates the magic number of Zombies - five. Gravespawn Sovereign plus Noosegraf Mob means that you get a new Noosegraf Mob for every five spells that get cast and that the game quickly spirals out of control if no one has a sweeper. The best part about Gisa and Geralf? You can just play a bunch of self-mill cards and Dread Return to cheat either half of the combo into play and jumpstart your engine.
The problem with Gisa and Geralf was always that it was eminently fair. The zombies that mill you are fairly bad and your engine is awfully slow to get started and easy to disrupt. You're very slow to rebuild after sweepers and have no protection from graveyard hate. It's a great deck for really casual games, but it doesn't hold up against more cohesive strategies. In fact, my favorite memory of this deck is from PAX Unplugged, where I met BehrendNinja because we were both playing G&G and we both died to her Triskaidekaphobia.
TWINSIES. @BehrendNinja pic.twitter.com/KqQAGPrlZa— Carlos (@cag5383) December 1, 2018
Highlight so far: Gisa and Geralf tag team ends in a triskaidekaphobia TRIPLE KILL?!?!?! @BehrendNinja pic.twitter.com/xsjmjx5jq3— Carlos (@cag5383) December 1, 2018

My question has always been whether or not those zombies are good enough in a format that goes as big as Commander. Sure, a bunch of zombies are powerful, but they're no Craterhoof Behemoth. Gravespawn Sovereign allows you to change all of that, because every land drop lets you start rebuying all the scariest creatures that have come and gone before. At instant speed. If someone sweeps the board, you can just play another land and be almost ready to go off again. Is this good enough to build a deck around? I intend to find out next weekend at PAX Unplugged.


