Sunday, November 29, 2020

Breaking Down U150: Banned List and Staples

 In the last post, I broke down the basics of the format. This time I want to start getting into the details and help people start thinking about how games play, how to build decks, and what kinds of things are legal. To that end, let's start with the cards that aren't legal and get that out of the way.

The banned list for the existing format is a little bit of a mystery. There's a list on the homepage for the format, but that list seems to disagree with random posts that I saw on the facebook page. So I don't know which set of things to trust. Consequently, I'm going to use the list that's an actual list and all in one place as a starting point and go from there. Here's the list of cards that are banned in the 'official' format. There are three lists - first the cards that are outright banned, follow by two lists of cards which cannot be played together.

Banned List
Restricted List A
Restricted List B
Some of these cards make a lot of sense to me. Others seem completely nonsensical. In general, it seems like cards fall into a couple of categories. Let's break the down.

Combotastic Synergies

I did not know that there were infinite combos in Pokemon, but I guess I shouldn't be shocked. These three Pokemon form the core of a common infinite that I suppose it makes sense to ban. The cards combo with any 'Rain Dance' style pokemon like Blastoise that lets you play multiple energies per turn.

It's fairly trivial to find Shuckle, with teams up with your Rain Dancer to draw a bunch of cards. There's a handful of ways to pick up your Shuckle and all the energies attached to it to do it all over again and draw a whole bunch of cards. The trick is to do this until you can find and play Espeon, which lets you pick up energies for free. Now you can play energies one at a time until you draw your deck. From there, you can do the same trick, but with Forretress to slowly knock out all of the opposing Pokemon.

No thanks, I'd rather not deal with this. I don't know that all the pieces need to be banned, but I'm having a hard time imagining much good coming from them being legal. I guess Shuckle is kind of interesting just as a draw engine, but is that worth it? Probably not.

Prison Effects



A number of the banned cards seem to boil down to Pokemon that easily lock opponents out of taking key game actions. I'm not sure that I've played enough games to know why these ones are banned while others aren't, but I'll take a stab.

Prison effects seem to be a key part of the Pokemon game. Some research shows that formats have been defined by some cards like Vileplume, Aerodactyl, Zebstrika, and Garbodor. A large number of decks that I've been people build for this format play Spiritomb. 

Generally speaking, it looks like the decision on which of these effects are too good boils down to a combination of whether or not the effect is one-sided, how easy it is to get into play, and how fragile it is. One-sided attacks, especially those that don't require much set up in terms of evolutions or energies, seem to be clearly over the line. Static powers with exceptions that you get to build around while your opponent cannot also seem to be too good.

Raw Efficiency


There's a couple of kinds of things going on here, but the gist of it is that these cards are very efficient. It seems to me that the question is when 'very efficient' becomes 'too efficient.'

Burning Roar off of Entei is an easy way to set up for a follow up Combat Blaze. In my limited experience, bench space is at a premium and I guess I can imagine that a two-energy attack that regularly hits for 80-120 with minimal setup is pretty unreasonable, especially since the attack also sets up your other pokemon and is attached to a high HP basic.

Trashalanche off of Garbodor is the same kind of thing. Sure, it's an evolution Pokemon, but believe me when I say that that attack can very consistently hit for 200+ damage with minimal setup.

Sableye rebuying items seems pretty good, but I don't know if I'm convinced that it's too good. My limited experience tells me that Pokemon is a game where resources are pretty free, but tempo is what's important. Investing an entire turn and an energy into rebuying cards feels like a very real cost to me. I'm definitely willing to believe that I'm wrong and this card is exceedingly unfun, especially in conjunction with something like Crushing Hammer or Hypnotoxic Laser.

Miltank is next, and I'll be honest - I truly do not understand why this card would be banned. One energy for potentially 80 damage is no joke, but it requires set up. Getting Stage 2 pokemon into play seems like a real cost to me, especially when there are so many forced switches running around to snipe key players off of your bench. There are so many unfair things that you can be doing in this game that I don't see why this is particularly egregious.

Last, we've got Greninja BREAK. If you can get this into play eary, targeted 60 damage per turn is a huge deal. Sniping off utility pokemon without needing to be the active pokemon, much less attack, feels a little beyond the pale.

Oops, I Win


One more card that's in its own category because it's something that I didn't think about. Seeker seems kind of innocuous on its face and might genuinely be okay given the new rules update on supporters. The problem with this card was that it could frrequently lead to wins on the first turn of the game. If your opponent only leads with one pokemon and you can find a way to kill it outside of combat, you just win the game. That might seem like a difficult thing to do, but lots of basic pokemon only have ~60 HP, and there are lots of cards like Galarian Zigzagoon and its evolutions that just stack up damage. Combine those with some Scoop Up effects and a Seeker to bounce your opponent's backup pokemon and it's not nearly as difficult to imagine a fairly consistent means of ending games before they really start.

Restricted List Interactions   

The cards on the restricted list seem to be trying to break up a pretty straightforward combination to me. Pokemon that can shuffle damage around and pokemon that can heal it off. Alakazam and Reuniclus can put damage wherever it's convenient to have. You can stack up damage on cards like Jumpluff or Lopunny and just bounce them back to your hand.

I doln't know why the cards that rebuy pokemon tools are on this list too. Maybe it's because of denying opponent's prizes with Life Dew? I can't find anything exactly like the Lopunny interactions, but I'm sure there's some kind of reason.

Approach to Deckbuilding

First thing's first - you do not want to be playing fair in this game. You should be looking to find something that feels degenerate. That could be cheating extra energies into play, ramping out Stage 2 Pokemon, or setting up huge attacks with Basic or Stage 1 Pokemon early in the game. There are lots of ways to lock your opponent out of different kinds of trainers or spread damage among fragile bench pokemon. There's 20-some years of cards and lots of cool space to explore - just don't fool yourself into thinking that this plays like Magic.

The biggest difference is that there aren't color requirements to play most of the cards. Trainers, Items, and Supporters are going to make up something like 50% or more of most decks, and they have no 'color identity' associated with them. The effects of these cards range from allowing you to draw a bunch of extra cards to searching your deck for specific pokemon. There are pokemon that have these kinds of effects too, and a lot of them don't require you to actually invest any energies to use them.

What does this all mean? A couple things. First and foremost, your goal should be to make sure that you can look at a lot of cards, very quickly. That's key to making sure that you can consistently execute your gameplan quickly. Second, you should be prepared for a lot of decks to start with a lot of similar support cards.

Because there are so many powerful trainers that fit into decks regardless of archetype or 'color,' there's a fairly long list of things that you should consider including in just about every deck. What follows is my trying to categorize and list some of the cards that seem like they should at least be considered for the majority of decks with the idea that it will give people someplace to start.

Sunday, November 15, 2020

Pokemon Singleton - Reverse Engineering Unlimited 150

About two months ago, I started asking if some friends would be interested in trying to make a Commander-ish format out of the Pokemon TCG. After a little bit of back and forth, I started doing some research and discovered that people had previously started doing work on exactly the kind of thing I was looking for.

Realistically, Unlimited 150 is a 100 card, singleton format that has a lot more in common with something like Canadian Highlander than Commander, but it's definitely a good place to start. Currently, I'm planning on writing a series of three posts about this:

  1. Introduction to the Format
  2. Staples, the banned list, and my watch list
  3. Basic deck construction and some decklists

The first thing I want to clarify is that, for reasons that we're about to get into, I very much do not want to play actual U150, but rather use it as a point for jumping off and discover if there's a fun game to add to the rotation of things that I regularly play with friends.

In digging around, I was able to find a number of interesting resources for the Unlimited 150. I'm going to do my best to break down what I've learned and what my takeaways are, but I encourage anyone interested to go do their own digging.

Official Pokemon Rules

If you're completely unfamiliar with the Pokemon TCG (or haven't played since the GBC game, like me), I'd recommend starting with this Tolarian Community College video to get the gist of the rules.

In general, the goal is to win by either knocking out all of your opponent's pokemon, taking all six of your prizes, or decking. You'll do that in a fashion which is very similar to magic. You've got a main phase where you can play Pokemon, items, and up to one supporter card. Much like your land drop in Magic, you can attach one energy card per turn. Finally, you can make one attack that immediately ends your turn.

Some caveats that aren't necessarily immediately obvious:
  • Mulligans are only a thing if you don't have a basic pokemon in your opening hand. If this is the case, you have to reveal your hand to your opponent and shuffle up again. You repeat this process until you find a hand with a basic pokemon, but you do not go down to fewer starting cards in hand.
  • Pokemon can't evolve on a player's first turn or the first turn that pokemon comes into play. For example, you cannot play a Wartortle from your hand to evolve a Squirtle on turn one. Similarly, once you do play your Wartortle, you'll have to wait until the following turn to play your Blastoise. There are cards that break these rules, but we'll get to those at a later point.
  • The player going first does get to draw a card on their first turn. However, they do not get to make an attack or play a supporter on their first turn.

U150 Rules

One of the objections I have with U150 is that it has a very involved set of rules that are very hard to decipher if you are not deeply entrenched in the game. Still, in order to give people the same kind of starting point, I'm going to break down their rule set as briefly as I can here.

On Deck Construction

Decks are 100 cards and singleton besides basic energies. Your deck can only include four copies of any card with the same name. This is important because, unlike in Magic, names of pokemon cards are not necessarily unique. If you do a search for Eevee, for example, there are many different Eevees that do different things. You can play up to four unique copies of cards named eevee to give you deck something resembling consistency.

There's also a banned list and two restricted lists for this format, but we'll get into those later.

On Prizes and Mulligans

100 card singleton means that decks are much more inconsistent than they usually are. Additionally, crucial cards being 'prized' (randomly chosen as one of your six prize cards) means that you may not have access to key cards. Their solution is that players draw a fifteen card hand and select which eight of those fiteen cards will be their prizes for the game. This means that U150 uses eight prizes instead of six and that you get a huge amount of selection about what is in your hand and you won't be surprised as to what tools are unavailable to you in the early game.

In addition, each player gets one free mulligan if they don't like their initial fifteen card hand.

On the Legality of Pokemon

Like many other games, Pokemon has an enormous amount of power creep. Just compare the relative sizes of these pokemon to get an idea of how radically the game has changed over the years. Looking at the HP should give you some idea, but also the EX and TAG TEAM pokemon are basics! 
The short story is that older pokemon cards have absolutely no way of keeping up with how newer cards have scaled. The HP and damage on newer cards is just so much higher that they outclass huge portions of the cards that have been printed. The way that this is balanced is that these EX and GX pokemon are typically worth more than one prize when you knock them out, but the raw stats on them are just incredibly overwhelming.

Here's where the name of the format comes in. In Unlimited 150, basic pokemon with more than 150 HP are banned. That means that Blastoise EX and Blastoise & Piplup GX would not be legal in U150. There will absolutely still be older cards that are very much outclassed by newer ones, but this does a good job in making sure that you can reasonably play decks that are not built around monstrously efficient Pokemon EX, GX, or TAG TEAMs.

Friday, June 12, 2020

Free Gifts Ungiven

Today I want to talk about my favorite card of all time: Gifts Ungiven. Gifts is a card that has been used for a lot of interesting things in an enormous number of formats, from Kamigawa Block Constructed all the way through Vintage. It's also a card that's currently banned in Commander.

The crux of this is that my very biased opinion is that Gifts should be legal in Commander. That it is no more degenerate than a myriad of other cards that are already legal and that its existence on the banned list is uniquely perplexing.

I want to start by looking at the kinds of things that Gifts does in the formats it's been legal in to give some context for the kinds of games that it can contribute to. Those things can range from super interactive to incredibly linear and everything in between. If that's not your thing, you can feel free to skip to the next break.

_________________________________________________________________________________

Gifts in Block Constructed

In Block, Gifts was a dominating strategy. The idea was that you could play a grindy control deck that used Gifts as a late game engine. Sensei's Divining Top teamed up with Gifts, Sakura-Tribe Elder and Kodama's Reach to give you an enormous amount of selection. Your gifts piles frequently included Hana Kami, Soulless Revival, and Eerie Procession (which served as a second copy of Soulless Revival). The idea was that you could then start splicing Soulless Revival onto your various Arcane spells to rebuy Hana Kami over and over again. You'd slowly lock the game out by looping spells like Hideous Laughter, Cranial Extraction, and Ethereal Haze.

Spliced Gifts by Frank Karsten

Gifts in Standard

Ever since watching Frank Karsten crush Worlds in 2005 with it, Greater Gifts has been one of my favorite decks of all time. This deck shares a lot of ideas with the Block Constructed version of the deck. There's still Sakura-Tribe Elder, Farseek, and Kodama's Reach as fixing and acceleration. There's still exactly two unique removal spells. Now there are two unique recursion spells to make Gifts piles easier in Reclaim and Recollect. The key difference between this deck and the Block one is the end game. This time the end game involves sacrificing Kokusho and Yosei to Greater Good over and over again courtesy of Goryo's Vengeance. It's worth noting that this is the deck that first popularized the gameplay pattern of using Gifts as a double Entomb to guarantee that your Kagemaro, Kokusho, or Yosei ended up in the graveyard.

Gifts in Extended

Extended is where some of my favorite Gifts decks of all time have existed. This is the format where the cardpool starts to get deep enough that you can play tons of singletons to get into some really interesting Gifts piles. This is where you'd first see Gifts paired with Life from the Loam and Academy Ruins to loop artifacts like Engineered Explosives or Mindslaver if you were given enough time. It's also where you'd see Gifts paired with Glittering Wish and Living Wish for even more flexibility. This is also where we start seeing cards that want to end up in the graveyard as part of Gifts piles, such as Cabal Therapy and Genesis. 



Gifts in Modern

This is, admittedly, where things start to go a little off the rails. Gifts in Modern is primarily relegated to two things. You are either setting up a storm kill with Past in Flames or setting up an Unburial Rites. The format is too fast and too diverse for anything else to really be worthwhile. That said, that hasn't stopped people from exploring Rock-style decks with Gifts Ungiven featuring the likes of Lingering Souls, Life from the Loam, and retrace spells.

For how linear Gifts frequently is in Modern, this deck shows off the kinds of things I wish were possible. Gifts packages involving Life from the Loam left you start looping utility lands like Ghost Quarter, Gavony Township, and Treetop Village. You can set up Urborg, Tomb of Yawgmoth and Raven's Crime in attrition-heavy matchups. You can do all kinds of crazy Sun Titan tricks in conjunction with Liliana of the Veil and Knight of the Reliquary. Sure, there are some fairly linear choices, but there's also an infinitely complex and interesting puzzle of non-standard piles that include mixes of removal spells, lands, and other key pieces.

Gifts Legacy and Vintage

Here's the thing: Gifts Ungiven doesn't really see play in Legacy and Vintage. There was a time when Gifts was restricted in Vintage, but both formats have really passed it by. Intuition still sees occasional play in Legacy as a way to set up Accumulated Knowledge, Life from the Loam, or Sevinne's Reclamation, but that's about the end of it. To my knowledge, the original Gifts deck in Vintage was Meandeck Gifts - a deck fundamentally built around the pile of Yawgmoth's Will, Tinker, Recoup, and Time Walk. That said, in Vintage you have enough busted singletons that there are all manner of interesting piles involving Ancestral Recall and Yawgmoth's Will or just piles of mana. That flexibility led to a lot of interesting choices until Paradoxical Outcome came around and did all of those things better.

_____________________________________________________________________

Gifts In Commander

So what does this mean for Commander? Gifts is a card with a really interesting legacy that only sees niche play these days. It's banned in Commander for many of the reasons that it's played in Modern. It has the potential to be an instant-speed way to set up a super linear way of either ending the game on the spot or locking your opponent out of the game. 

Gifts Ungiven is unlike any other card on the banned list. It doesn't fit the old 'egregiously expensive' criteria for things like Power. It isn't a permanent that centralizes the rest of the game on itself like Primeval Titan, Sylvan Primordial, or Griselbrand. It's not a busted mana engine like Tolarian Academy. It doesn't immediately bury the table in cards like Yawgmoth's Bargain. It doesn't cheat anything into play like Tinker. It doesn't reset the game. Gifts is a tutor that is only ever as good as the supporting cast. Let's be clear, there are absolutely dozens of Gifts piles across ever possible color combination that will end games. 

Some people choose to push Commander to the limits with cEDH. At higher-power tables, an end step Gifts will probably lead to someone untapping and winning the game. That said, there are plenty of cEDH decks that can easily be ported down for budget decks and lower-power builds. Despite that, I never see Godo or Najeela combo off. I rarely see games won off of Laboratory Maniac. I've never seen a Gitrog Monster deck combo off with state-based effects. If someone wants to do something busted in your games, they already have all the tools they need to do so - the legality of Gifts Ungiven isn't going to fundamentally change that.

If we're going to judge Gifts based on its worst-case scenario, then what about other tutors? Why are they exempt from that criteria? Are we really going to argue that Gifts Ungiven is more efficient or has more unfair applications than the likes of vintage staples like Vampiric Tutor and Demonic Tutor? I have never seen a Tainted Pact or Demonic Consultation cast in the absence of Thassa's Oracle or Laboratory Maniac. Despite that, we still see people casting tutors for lands, silver bullets, and answers in lower-powered games. Fundamentally, people can and do play fair with busted tutors. We've collectively agreed not to judge them based on their most unfair applications, but to let different people play with them in different ways.

People who want to break Gifts are going to break it, there's absolutely no question about that. That said, just slotting Gifts into an existing deck is unlikely to break it. Some people will just get some combination of four haymakers and answers. Still others will do something in between that sets up some kind of value engine. This dichotomy of fair and unfair applications isn't unique to Gifts Ungiven. What is unique is that Gifts Ungiven is banned while every other tutor that has ever been printed (sans Tinker and Primeval Titan) is legal.
TLDR

All I'm trying to say is that it seems odd to me that Gifts Ungiven is the single tutor in the entirety of Magic that crosses the line on power, efficiency, or gameplay concerns. If we can be trusted to play with degenerate engines like Hermit Druid and super efficient tutors like Demonic Tutor without breaking Rule 0, I think we can be trusted to have Gifts Ungiven.

Tuesday, June 9, 2020

Let's Talk About Interaction

It shouldn't be a secret to anyone that I've soured quite a bit on Magic in general and Commander in particular over the last couple of years. Some amount of that is that the game and format are very different than they used to be and I'm getting to a curmudgeon-y age. But I think that some amount of my concerns are real, learnable, and I'm starting to find the words to articulate my dissastisfaction.

Fundamentally, I think my issue is that, more and more frequently, I'm seeing decks fall into one of three categories, all of which can be responsible creating different kinds of non-games:

  • Get ahead, stay ahead
  • Go Bigger
  • Unbreakable Value
Let's break these down briefly.


Get Ahead, Stay Ahead


These are decks that want to get on the board quickly and generate an overwhelming advantage early in the game. Think Commanders like Winota, Krenko, Animar, and Najeela. These frequently let you cheat on mana to cast more spells than your opponents early in the game and generate an insurmountable advantage if you aren't interacted with early and often.


Go Bigger

These are decks that largely want to ignore their opponent and play a bunch of set up spells. Usually ramp spells, mana rocks, and then a few key 'combo' pieces that let you leverage that mana into an enormous advantage. I think about commanders like Wort, the Raidmother, Kinnan, and Zacama, which can be primarily  composed of ramp spells and payoffs. If they have time to execute their plans, you're going to get absolutely buried in mana advantage or just get 'combo killed' because they can play multiple haymakers in a turn.

Unbreakable Value

These are decks that try to set up an unbreakable board full of small moving pieces that give you built in protection, redundancy, and resiliency. I think of aristocrat commanders like Athreos, Teshar, and Gerard that try to build up an engine that slowly accrues more and more value and becomes increasingly difficult to break apart. Think about sacrifice outlets and recursion and Blood Arists and Grave Pacts that slowly lock opponents out of different aspects of the game, become increasingly resilient to creature and graveyard interaction, and slowly draw more cards and drain more life turn after turn.

Why Does This Matter?

I want to be clear - there's nothing fundamentally wrong with pursuing these kinds of strategies - many of my decks fall into these broad generalizations. The issue is that the pool of powerful, linear, and proactive cards is so much bigger now than it used to be. Decks are becoming increasingly streamlined with more mana acceleration, more redundancy, and more explosive potential.

Explosive decks have more two-mana rocks than ever before and cheap protection than ever before, and those cards are creeping into more and more decklists. The Go Big decks have a higher density of efficient ramp spells and an increasingly broad selection of powerful, synergistic payoffs. The value engine decks have more copies of Selfless Spirit, Grave Pact, and Scrap Trawler-esque effects.

As all of these decks become leaner and more focused, I'm seeing a higher proportion of non-games where one person gets to do their thing hard enough that the rest of the table is irrelevant. Frequently, that person will sort of shrug at the end of the game and say something to the effect of 'I thought people would have more interaction.'

But here's a thing that I'm noticing - when I get asked to look at decks, there's less and less interactive cards across the board. People are trimming on interaction to make space for more redundancy, more acceleration, more exciting and shiny proactive cards. The issue is that, when everyone does this, no one has the interaction that everyone else is expecting to keep them in check. That leas to more games quickly spiral out of control.

Some groups might be totally fine with that style of game - and that's completely fine! Personally, I think the fun part of the game is the midgame, where there's tension and posturing and politicking, in favor of games where the players could just as well be playing in separate rooms.

What Next?

I guess my recommendation is that people think about what kind of game they want to play and then take a look at how much and what types of interactive elements exist in their decks, as well as how compact, resilient, and redundant their core gameplan is. Does that combination contribute to the kind of games you and your friends enjoy?

Does your deck depend on combat or not? How many axes can your core gameplan be interacted on (e.g. counterspells, graveyard hate, artifact destruction, etc)? How much of your deck is dedicated to executing your own plan versus engaging with your opponents in a meaningful way? How quickly can you execute that plan and how much counterplay is available once you do? 

I did this exercise with the four decks that I had closest on hand, and I was honestly pretty surprised at the results.

Breaking My Decks Down

The four decks I had on hand were my Raff Capashen Superfriends deck, Teshar Midrange, Ephara Midrange, and Kemba Midrange.

I was shocked to find that Kemba had six total pieces of interaction, and that's if you count Karmic Justice, which is definitely a stretch. Raff played 17 pieces of interaction, but those were largely sweepers. That makes a clear statement that I really just want to ignore what everyone else is doing until I can execute my own plan rather than engaging with theirs in a meaningful way. Teshar dedicates fully twice as many cards to protecting my board rather than engaging with opponents. 

Ephara had the most interaction with a full 10 spot removal spells plus graveyard hate and sweepers - a full fifth of the deck is interactive cards. But here's the kicker: that hasn't felt like enough in those games. How much of that is that my balance is wrong? I don't know. But it's also possible that other decks at the table have been making the same decisions I have - cutting down on removal in the name of making space for more shiny proactive pieces.

Wrapping Up

So what's the point? Is it wrong for people to enjoy games where you just see who can execute their plan the fastest? Absolutely not. Games where people largely ignore each other and race to do busted stuff are part of Magic and some people live for it. It's not for me.

I want games where there's a push and pull and where most players get a chance to try to meaningfully execute their plan before someone runs away with it. A core part of those games is that everyone contributes interaction to help keep the game relatively stable while we all scramble to try to do our thing. A cursory review of my decks shows that, even though I enjoy that kind of game, I haven't been building my decks in a way that's consistent with that approach.

It's getting easier and easier to fall into the trap of packing your deck full of nothing but efficient, proactive, powerful cards. So I encourage everyone to take a few minutes to reflect on what kinds of games you've enjoyed the most - is it super compact? Battle cruiser? Midrangey? Politicky? Once you have that answer, honestly ask whether you're building decks that contribute to that style of game or not.

Monday, May 25, 2020

My Tireless Quest

There is no commander that has been more frustrating to me since it's printing than Golos. This card does everything that I want a Commander to do - it ramps you a non-basic land and encourages you to play expensive, five-color nonsense - so why am I struggling with it so much?


This fall, I built my first take on Golos. I even wrote about it. That deck had two goals. First, combine Golos and flicker effects, especially repeatable ones like Nim Deathmantle and Eldrazi Displacer to assemble crazy combinations of utility lands. Second, make many copies of Field of the Dead and bury the table in zombies.

That deck was very good, very consistent, and incredibly resilient. Frequently a single ramp spell meant you started making two zombies per land drop on the fifth turn of the game, and it only ramped up from there. Each flicker effect was more zombies, and even if your opponents had sweepers you could stock up on fetchlands or just recast your Commander and a flicker and suddenly you've got twelve Zombies again. It quickly becomes super overbearing presence at the table because it's incredibly difficult for opponents to actually break your board and buy themselves a turn to breathe and counterattack.

I got comments from my friends that it needed to be toned back. Way back. Some going as far as saying that it wasn't possible for a Golos deck to be casual. I tried cutting back on repeatable flickers. I tried cutting back on extra land drops. It still did the same thing, and I had to face the truth: the problem is Thespian's Stage and Vesuva. Sure, Parallel Lives and company are probably more unfair than extra copies of Field of the Dead in the absolute sense. But my Commander all but guarantees that I'll have three copies of Field of the Dead by turn six or seven every single game. The consistency and resiliency provided by that was the fundamental problem.

So if I have to change the foundational goal of my deck, where do we go from here? Just jamming your deck full of expensive haymakers like Praetors and Eldrazi is not my thing, and that feels like it also has the potential to feel overbearing at the table. I have an Emeria, the Sky Ruin deck, and building around Valakut in this shell feels even less fun that Field of the Dead.

What's in Your Head?

Introspection time. Setting aside the obvious land shenanigans, what is it about Field of the Dead that I enjoy so much? Realistically, I like the resiliency. I enjoy grinding in my games, so the core experience I'm looking for is slowly building up an overwhelming mass of zombies while The Cranberries play on repeat in my head.

Okay. That's something to work with. So what if I just played with one Field of the Dead? There are plenty of other, non-land ways to make more zombie tokens to keep the feeling the same while lowering the power level. I could even add more cards that lean into the zombie token theme instead of the generically powerful cards. What if we made Golos a Zombie tribal deck where Field of the Dead makes you less sad about sweepers?

I had recently taken apart a Gisa and Geralf deck, and promptly started digging through my collection to find those pieces. I ended up swapping up about twenty non-land cards - fully half of the ones in the deck - to end up with something that is hopefully both very similar and very different to what I had before. Here's the things that made the cut:

  1. Gravespawn Sovereign
  2. Genesis
  3. Corpse Connoisseur
  4. Death Baron
  5. Dark Impostor
  6. Josu Vess, Lich Knight
  7. Noosegraf Mob
  8. Vindictive Lich
  9. Grave Titan
  10. Soul of Innistrad
  11. Vizier of Many Faces
  12. Rot Hulk
  13. Liliana, Untouched by Death
  14. Ever After
  15. Dread Return
  16. Silence the Believers
  17. Rescue from the Underworld
  18. Buried Alive
The core idea here was to add a core Zombie package of Grave Titan, Gravespawn Sovereign, Noosegraf Mob, and Rot Hulk. These cards play well with one another, as all the zombies team up with Gravespawn Sovereign and sacrifice outlets to ensure that your zombie presence continues to grow. They also generally play well with flickers to still generate a board presence that's difficult to break up, but in a way that's easier for opponents to interact with and harder for me to assemble.

In addition to that, we've got some cool ways to play out of the graveyard. I'm not sure that Genesis is necessary, but I love Buried Alive and Corpse Connoisseur as ways to set up the graveyard for Ever After and Liliana, Untouched by Death. I also love Soul of Innistrad, Vizier of Many Faces, and Liliana, Untouched by Death giving you pseudo-flashback creatures.


Josu Vess is an interesting choice. I picked it over Army of the Damned because it's a creature. That said, the only ways to rebuy it are Soul of Innistrad and Genesis, so maybe it either needs more support or isn't worthwhile. I don't want that to be a card like Empty the Pits, which is a little too easy to pair with Cabal Coffers to just end the game on someone's end step out of nowhere.

We've also got Silence the Believers and Dark Impostor as mana sinks for Cabal Coffers. If we're going to try to cast giant zombies and still be activating Golos, we're going to need to focus more on Coffers plus Urborg - it's probably even worthwhile to find space for Cabal Stronghold and potentially Nykthos as backup.

The Aftermath

I've gotten two games in with this deck since I rebuilt it, and I think I'm much happier with it. You still do Zombie things - Noosegraf mob is an absolute joy to play with - but you have to work much harder to do them, which is roughly what I was looking for. You have to make difficult choices between casting your spells, activating Golos, or leaving up lands to do things like pay for Nim Deathmantle or Gavony Township.

There are still some things to worry about - the potential to loop Vindictive Lich a few times with Nim Deathmantle or Soul of Innistrad to just kill someone from a high life total, for example. Generally speaking though, I'm much happier with the Zombie list than I was with the Field of the Dead list. There's still a couple interesting questions that I want to work on, but those are for future me:

  1. I played a 15+ turn game yesterday where I still had a hand full of lands at the end of the game. Are cards that allow multiple land drops more acceptable now that there are fewer Field triggers?
  2. Is it worthwhile to try to build around looping hideaway lands with karoos as a way to dig for more zombie spells and give the deck more instant-speed ways to do things?
  3. Pseudo-lords like Gleaming Overseer, Aven Wind Guide, Risen Executioner, Eternal Skylord, and Necromancer's Covenant are almost certainly worth considering.
  4. Varina, Lich Queen? Is this a reasonable way to turn lands into gas and/or stock the graveyard? The deck doesn't have a ton of non-creature recursion anymore, so I'm not sure if looting is what I want or not.
  5. How good is Endless Ranks of the Dead? It rarely made it around the table in my previous Zombie builds, but maybe it's worth trying again.




Saturday, March 7, 2020

Common Commander

One of my least favorite things about Commander is how pricey so many of the core cards have become. I've already got a substantive collection, so I can usually cannibalize one or more existing projects rather than dropping a few hundred dollars on a new deck. That's an enormous privilege that I have because I've been playing for multiple decades.

There's an incredible amount of great budget commander content is a testament to how dedicated the community is to ensuring that anyone can play, regardless of their budget. That said, decks that I built on a tight budget 10 years ago are now worth several hundred dollars purely because of cards that haven't been reprinted at the same pace that Commander demand has grown.

One of my favorite budget projects from back in the day was a Pauper Commander deck - the Commander of your choice backed up by nothing but commons. It was honestly an interesting challenge back in 2010ish and I was actually able to build a very reasonable Child of Alara deck that could reasonably keep pace with most casual tables. I thought it would be interesting to revisit that project and see how budget friendly it was in 2020.

After looking at my old list and making some updates for sets that have come out since I last updated it, this is where I ended up. There's four key categories of cards in this deck. Let's briefly break them down.

Acceleration and Fixing

This is absolutely key. Playing a 5-Color deck without the best dual lands and mana rocks is not an easy feat. Cards like Kodama's Reach and Cultivate are superstars. Mycosynth Wellspring and Darksteel Ingot are critical early fixing. Farhaven Elf even plays really well with all the powerful recursion and flicker effects. Perhaps the most important ramp spell in the entire deck is Far Wanderings. Three lands for one card is a stellar way of setting up the powerful recursion loops that this deck relies on.

Card Advantage

Pound for pound, the cards in this deck are substantially worse than the average Commander deck. That's especially true now that so many Commanders are busted value engines unto themselves. With that in mind, you've got to be able to generate enough value to keep up with a table's worth of opponents. Cards like Secrets of the Golden City and Treasure Cruise are key to ensuring that you can keep up.

That said, the real plan here is the combination of buyback spells, creatures that buyback spells like Archaeomancer, and recursion spells like Grim Harvest, Capsize, and Ghostly Flicker. These varied recursion engines team up with your limited suite of targeted answers to ensure that you can keep the board relatively stable.

The Child Engine

In general, your gameplan is to use spot removal to keep the board at parity. Sometimes that won't be possible - someone will have gotten too far ahead. That's what Child is for. The gameplan here is to find various ways to sacrifice Child for value over and over again. The best version of this effect is Mind Extraction, which sweeps the board and discards your opponent's hand. The other exciting ones are Perilous Research and Altar's Reap, both of which let you kill Child at instant-speed. Sidisi's Faithful may seem out of place in a value-oriented deck like this, but you can stack triggers such that Sidisi's Faithful bounces itself before Child's trigger resolves.

The other half of the engine is the myriad of ways to rebuy Child and ensure that you can sweep the board all over again if things get out of hand. From Mortuary Mire plus bouncelands to Grim Harest and Disturbed Burial, you've got all manner of ways to ensure that you don't run out of ways to keep Child on the board.

The Combo Finish

There's lots of ways to try to end the game with this deck depending on how you want to construct it. This build opts to combine Ghostly Flicker, Cloud of Faeries, a Mnemonic Wall effect, and multiple bouncelands to generate infinite mana for Rolling Thunder. Other options include things like Lifespark Spellbomb and Freed from the Real, flickering Dinrova Horror over and over again, or even just beating down with Child of Alara.

But What About Budget?

Now that you know what the deck is trying to do, let's take a look at how budget-friendly it is. The build that I'd throw together out of my collection comes in at about $100. In the overall scheme of things that's not terrible - but it is awfully pricey for a deck full of commons, especially when I was able to build it for about $30 back in 2010. This isn't even including the possibility of playing Snow basics and Skred as another efficient removal spell - that alone is going to add another $15-20 to the cost of the deck.

A lot of the price is in just a handful of cards that have increased in demand without any kind of reprint. Things like Rhystic Study, Merchant Scroll, Preordain, and Path of Ancestry are pretty hefty chunk of the value of this deck. But are these budget-breakers critical to how the deck functions? Not especially. Here's some recommendations for taking this and bringing the price more in line with what you might expect for a pile of commons.
  • Cloud of Faeries → Peregrine Drake or another piece of a combo finish. 
  • Sakura-Tribe Elder → Rampant Growth
  • Farhaven Elf → Ondu Giant
  • Expedition Map → Reap and Sow
  • Wayfarer's Bauble → Font of Fertility / Embodiment of Spring
  • Trinket Mage → Vedalken Aethermage
  • Rhystic Study → Read the Bones
  • Counterspell → Arcane Denial
  • Muddle the Mixture → Deprive
  • Preordain → Portent
  • Merchant Scroll → Brainspoil
  • Kodama's Reach → Grow from the Ashes
  • Primal Growth → Deep Reconnaissance
  • Path of Ancestry → Cave of Temptation
This is just an example of how you can find cards that fill similar functionalities to bring down the price of the deck. There are plenty of cards in your piles of draft commons that fill similar roles and let you play with favorites from Limited formats past. Is the deck better if you can play more of the few tutors that have been printed at common? Absolutely. But they aren't necessary if you're more concerned about budget than theme. These changes bring the price of the deck down to right around $40, and there's still plenty of cards in the $1-2 range that you could swap out for other things if you were so inclined.

The pieces here are fairly generic - you'd like to play the most efficient or most flexible version of the various counterspells, ramp spells, and recursion effects. But if you want to bring the price down or just don't have access to them, then just replace them with something more affordable. Is Ghostly Flicker better than Displace? Sure - but only because it can occasionally blink lands. Counterspell is certainly better than Cancel or Arcane Denial, but you can absolutely get by with budget options, metagame calls, or even just ones that bring back good memories from old formats.

Cards like Pyroblast and Hydroblast are great ways to kill your Child of Alara or target key players in your local metagame. You could absolutely add more cards like Forsake the Worldly or Rend Flesh. Look through your collection for cards that fill the roles that the deck needs, supplement with powerful commons that are in your budget. There's no end to hyper-specific, powerful answers like Ancient Grudge and Ray of Revelation, even in Pauper. You don't even have to stick to commons - Blood for Bones and Rescue from the Underworld are great sacrifice outlets. You can go even bigger with Momentous Fall or Morbid Curiosity.

The moral of the story is that you don't have to break your budget to build a deck that does powerful things. Find a powerful effect, back it up with card advantage, answers, and the best ramp you can find, and you'll be just fine.

Thursday, January 30, 2020

Mowu, Best Boy

Over the years, we've struggled to find a way for my wife to play Commander. She enjoys the art and story of Magic, but struggles to get super engaged with actual gameplay. Games of Commander have a really high learning curve, and the additional complexity of multiple players makes it really hard to keep track of all of the moving pieces.

We've tried a couple of approaches to try to find a deck that's accessible - something that has an appealing theme and interacts in a fairly straightforward way:


  • Oloro Birds - the idea here was to pair cheap birds with the card drawing and lifegain from Oloro and a couple splashy haymakers. Tracking this many color requirements and trying to manage Oloro triggers was a lot. It didn't help that birds are a relatively low-power strategy, particularly if you're focusing on fun bird art rather than the limited tribal support that's available.
  • Archangel Avacyn - this was a deck that was focused on using equipment and cards like Crimson Acolyte to leverage the flip trigger off of Avacyn as a political tool. The issue here is that my wife didn't really like trying to play on other players' turns. In addition to that, trying to figure out how to manage the timing of Avacyn's trigger and prioritize all of the subtle changes you could apply to it was a little too daunting.
  • Karametra Ramp - this deck did the typical Karametra thing. Creatures that bounce themselves paired with cheap value creatures let you ramp into giant haymakers and grind out some value. This was probably the most successful experiment because it's the most linear and powerful. However, the various value creature loops were a little difficult to manage.
  • Ghalta - this was the most recent experiment. The goal here was to take a dinosaur tribal Brawl deck and make it into a Commander deck. The problem is that Ghalta is, for most purposes, a vanilla creature. She may be very large and very cheap, but vanilla creatures are not frequently what Commander was about. On top of that, there just isn't a particularly high density of powerful dinosaurs in Green, which just left this feeling underpowered relative to the table.
It's been a year or so since our last great Commander experiment, which means that it's time to take another stab at it. This time I wanted to shoot for something somewhere in between Ghalta and Karametra. Something with a looser theme, a fairly linear gameplan, and throw in a fun Commander at the helm to boot.

Let's see what the best boy can do. In and of himself, Mowu is pretty inefficient. But there are some fairly straightforward play patterns that can quickly help Mowu get out of control. A linear, combat-focused Commander that plays to the board might be the perfect way to dive back in.


The first thing we're looking for are ways to make sure that Mowu scales over the course of the game - ideally cards that let you add +1/+1 counters turn after turn. Here's what I was able to find:
  • Armory of Iroas
  • Ring of Kalonia
  • Forced Adaptation
  • Predatory Hunger
  • Hydra's Growth
  • Retreat to Kazandu
  • Hardened Scales
  • Pir, Imaginative Rascal
  • Ivy Lane Denizen
  • Evolution Sage
All of these cards help ensure that you can ramp up Mowu's size turn after turn. The goal is to ensure that Mowu is a consistent threat that scales over the course of the game and can't be ignored by the rest of the table. If people underestimate the best boy, Commander damage will slowly stack up over the course of a game and Mowu will start threatening to knock people out.

Of course, that only works is Mowu stays in play for multiple turns - that's certainly not something that's guaranteed. Much like with Ghalta, the goal has to be to resolve and protect Mowu from as many things as possible. There's a reasonable number of protection spells available in Green, and some that even play into the +1/+1 counter theme:
  • Blossoming Defense
  • Ranger's Guile
  • Withstand Death
  • Mortal's Resolve
  • Sheltering Word
  • Inspiring Call
  • Swiftfoot Boots
This is a lower density of protection than I would really like, but your choices drop off fairly quickly. Depending on what your budget looks like and what kind of removal you're trying to dodge, there are plentiful equipment options ranging from Champion's Helm to Darksteel Plate. I'd love more combat tricks, but this is what's currently available.

There are still three more things that this deck is in desperate need of. The first is acceleration. Casting a Hill Giant on turn 4, suiting them up on turn 5, and hoping to start attacking on turn 6 is a tall order. Traditional green ramp is fine. Spells that let you get from two mana to four are particularly valuable, and this deck is less likely to care about the card advantage of spells like Cultivate. That said, there are several mana creatures that scale with power - like Gyre Sage, Incubation Druid, and Marwyn. These cards are have particularly high potential.

The second thing the deck needs is a way to keep pace on cards. Harmonize and Rishkar's Expertise are only going to get you so far. Unlike many green decks, cards like Elemental Bond and Guardian Project aren't necessarily a great choice, since your primary gameplan isn't to cast a bunch of creatures, but to go tall with Mowu. Similarly, cards like Armorcraft Judge really want you to go wide, which isn't necessarily what Mowu wants to be doing. Instead, I've settled on effects that care about power. Colossal Might, Triumph of Ferocity, and Drumhunter are emblematic of what I'm looking for.

Lastly, Mowu needs ways to interact with the board. the focus here is going to be on fighting effects. There are plenty of effects like Savage Stomp that give you +1/+1 counters and fight - that's a great way to keep growing Mowu while maintaining board control. There's also the possibility of using Lure effects like Nemesis Mask and Provoke to force opponents to throw key creatures in front of Mowu so he can trample over. The viability of these plans depends on how consistently the deck can keep Mowu in play, and is something that's going to have to be felt out. Fill out the gaps with a handful of Disenchant effects and that should be a fairly good place to start.

With all of that in mind, here's where I've ended up for a first pass. I'll definitely still do some fussing around with how many lands the deck really wants and try to find the right balance of protection, pump spells, and fight effects.

Sunday, January 12, 2020

Ponderings on Pauper

For a long time, Pauper was one of my favorite ways to play Magic. When I first took an interest in the format, it was dominated by Cloudpost and Mulldrifter - two of my favorite cards of all time! - and was reminiscent of Magic the way I remembered playing it growing up.

The format has changed a lot since I first started paying attention, and largely for the better. Storm and Infect were too fast for the majority of decks to keep pace with. The lifegain provided by Glimmerpost made Cloudpost far too resilient against non-Infect aggressive strategies. Temporal Fissure locks backed up by anemic beatdown was a miserable play pattern. For each card on the banned list, there are similar examples of large blocks of strategies being rendered largely unplayable.

But what about contemporary Pauper? I still follow the format, but I stopped seriously playing about two years ago at this point. I've long been of the opinion that contemporary Pauper is not a particularly healthy format, but I've never really discussed it in a long-form format. So here goes.


What Does Healthy Mean?

Rather than starting with the things that have pushed me away from the format, I want to start with what, in my mind, are measures of a healthy format. I tried for awhile to come up with some cute heuristics - things like the viability of Mono-Black Midrange or something similar. Here's the thing, it all boils down to this: 

Interaction should matter. The core of the format should not revolve around trying to avoid engaging with your opponent in any way.

Is This Format Interactive?

When you take a glance at the overall metagame, I think it's reasonable to say that everything is fine. There's plenty of viable decks and a reasonable amount of counterplay, so everything's fine, right? Tron is the most represented deck - that's a control deck, so that's interactive. Blue tempo decks are represented, that's good as long as they aren't overbearing. The Boros monarch decks are midrangey, and you've got Burn, Stompy, Affinity, and Bogles as beatdown decks. There's even Elves as a combo strategy. So what's the problem?

Here's my question: how many of these decks actually care about what their opponents are doing in any substantial way?

The bulk of the interaction in Tron decks is in the form of Stonehorn Dignitary and effects like Moment's Peace and Prismatic Strands. There are a handful of counterspells, but those are mostly intended to protect your flickers from getting sniped by spot removal. Dinrova Horror is a kind of interaction, but is primarily a combo piece to help lock opponents out of the game with Ghostly Flicker. Does locking your opponent out of their combat step count as interaction? 

The Blue tempo strategies and Boros midrange are certainly interactive, though it looks like the Boros deck is presently leaning an awful lot on Prismatic Strands.

Sure, the Burn decks playing Searing Blaze. You even have Weather the Storm to try to beat them. The matchup against Spellstutter Sprite decks can be rather intricate. But calling the Pauper versions of these decks interactive is incredibly generous. The deck largely doesn't even depend on the combat step, at least in part due to the prevalence of Stonehorn Dignitary and Fogs.

Look at some of the Stompy, Bogles, and Affinity lists. Besides their explosive potential to win games before opponents get set up, how many ways to these decks have to dodge common forms of interaction? All of these decks have ways to shut off edicts. They all have ways to dodge blockers or win outside of combat. They all have ways to make removal spells embarrassing. All while presenting a very fast clock with resilient threats. How are you supposed to keep pace with all of these varied strategies without resorting to locking them out of combat?

All in all, I'd say that the overwhelming majority of decks are looking to do some combination of racing and ignoring opposing strategies while minimizing interaction points. I know there are plenty of people who enjoy these types of games. I'll also fully admit my bias and preference for formats where slow, interactive Blue decks are premier strategies. Regardless of your preference, I think it's worth asking whether this is the healthiest place for the format to be.

Root Cause?

Metagames are complicated ecosystems, and I'm not going to pretend to know what the best way to modify them is. The whole thing is a weird Jenga tower of interdependent pieces. Adding or removing a card to that ecosystem can have enormous and unexpected consequences. That said, here are a few of the issues I see:

Control decks are narrow and non-interactive. When the primary focus of control strategies is to lock opponents out of the game with Stonehorn Dignitary and Ghostly Flicker backed up by Moment's Peace and Prismatic Strands, that - to me - indicates that there is an underlying issue. The fact that there are no other serious control decks is also indicative of a problem.

Linear decks are far too explosive and resilient. Decks like Stompy, Affinity, Burn, and Bogles have existed since I've been playing the format. They've always been fine choices. They didn't always have cards like Burning-Tree Emissary, Ethereal Armor, and Thermoalchemist. The raw efficiency of these strategies combined with how diverse they all are puts an enormous amount of strain on 'fair' decks. Matchups become more about whether or not the answers you brought line up in a macro-sense and less about the choices you make in them. There are no generically good removal spells or sweepers. Even if you play a bunch of spot removal, it's not guaranteed to be efficient enough or line up well. That combination of things pushes players towards Fogs as a primary means of interaction.

Ghostly Flicker is bad for the format. I love this card and all the cute tricks it can do. I've flickered more Prophetic Prisms, Bojuka Bogs, and Serrated Arrows than I can reasonably count. The combination of Ghostly Flicker, Mnemonic Wall, and Capsize locks out all manner of strategies that could otherwise contend with Tron decks. There is can never be anything that's better at going to the late game than Ghostly Flicker decks that can generate infinite resources. Anything that tries to go later will get devoured by the linear strategies. The lack of variety in endgame for control decks is a bad thing for the format.

Monarch cards put a huge strain on the format. I've generally enjoyed the games that I play with Monarch cards in Pauper. That said, I think it's worth considering the two negative effects they can have on the format. First, control strategies are embarrassing against Monarch cards. Either you have a counterspell for every Monarch card over the course of a game, or you have to ignore their entire strategy and go way bigger with Ghostly Flickers. Against aggressive decks, you're encouraged to play a bunch of Prismatic Strands in conjunction with your Monarch cards to stabilize and maintain Monarch status against the explosive linear decks.

Edicts are enormously high variance. Depending on the matchup and how your draws line up, Edicts range from 'literally the only effect that gets you out of a bad situation' to 'utterly blank piece of cardboard'. They are one of the best ways to snipe high toughness creatures without getting got by hexproof or Vines of the Vastwood. But if your opponent has Young Wolf, Cartouche of Solidarity, or Flayer Husk, your edict is all but blank. For a long time, edicts were an important part of the ecosystem of Pauper removal spells. In recent years, they've incidentally lost a lot of their power and I'm not sure the format is better off for it.

Wrapping Up

So what's the point? I think I've done a reasonable job of outlining the things that have driven me away from the format. It's gotten a lot faster and - in my mind at least - less interactive than it used to be. Plenty of people will like the format as it is today better. There's nothing wrong with that. As long as people are playing and enjoying the format, it doesn't have to cater towards me in particular.

That said, I miss the days of Tron decks playing a bunch of Magma Sprays and Lightning Bolts. The games felt much more dynamic to me, and trying to figure out how to best line up your combination of removal and countermagic against Delver and Stompy decks is some of the most fun I've ever had playing Magic.

The format has changed a lot in recent years, and I think the discussion about whether the end result is better or worse than where we started is one that's worth having. I just wanted to take an opportunity to reflect on those changes as I see them and highlight some of the things that have made me less enthusiastic about the format.

Saturday, January 11, 2020

Chainer, Dragon Master


I have always had a fascination roundabout ways of doing things. The most well-known manifestation of this is probably my obsession with non-Green ramp leveraging cards like Surveyor's Scope, Second Sunrise, and Planar Birth, but it certainly doesn't end there.

I have a really vivid memory sometime in high school of someone posting a deck that I thought was the coolest thing in the world. It played Survival of the Fittest, Squee, Goblin Nabob, Krovikan Horror, Bazaar of Baghdad, and Zombie Infestation as an engine. Ever since then, I've been looking for opportunities to do something similar.

The closest I ever got was a Malfegor Commander deck. That deck was fine, but had a big shortcoming. It was very good at killing creatures, but very bad at everything else, including actually closing out games. It turns out it's hard to do that when your hand is empty all the time. That said, that deck taught me that there is a substantive engine that involves rebuying creatures to your hand and discarding them for value:


  • Squee, Goblin Nabob
  • Krovikan Horror
  • Death Spark
  • Veilborn Ghoul
  • Sandstorm Eidolon
  • Entropic Eidolon
  • Blood Speaker
You can leverage these cards with effects like Malfegor, Necromancer's Stockpile, Faithless Looting, and Tortured Existence to grind out card advantage that even Blue decks can be jealous of. Imagine my shock when I stumbled upon a new way to abuse this engine hidden among the sets that I didn't keep up with this year.


Chainer is a much better way to leverage the Squee-style engines than something like Malfegor, because it allows you to be far more proactive. On its own, that was exciting enough. Then my friend Jason (@realevilgenius) sent me a card that changed absolutely everything - Bladewing, the Risen.

The big downside of Chainer is that you can only use the effect once per turn. Setting aside flash creatures, that's a pretty harsh restriction. It means that you're never really going to net more than one card per turn. Bladewing changes all of that.

Presuming that you have enough cheap, utility effects to grind out the early game, you should be able to stock your graveyard full of dragons by discarding them to Chainer, Looting effects, or anything else. Casting Bladewing out of the graveyard lets you rebuy an additional dragon - with haste - and access to a global pump effect. That feels like it has the potential to be unfair, and I immediately set about trying to figure out what the best way to leverage that interaction.

The first thing we want is dragons that are worth the effort of reanimating. Things with big effects, especially when reanimated in multiples. Things like Kolaghan, the Storm's Fury, Drakuseth, and Lathliss are some of the most exciting options. The second thing we want is utility creatures can consistently end up in the graveyard. These are your Shriekmaws, Ingot Chewers, and Doomed Necromancers of the world. Last, we want creatures that help you develop your mana to be able to actually cast dragons. Burnished Hart may be one of the best examples, since Chainer can rebuy Burnished Hart multiple times, but various Myr, Pilgrim's Eye, and Skittering Surveyor are serviceable as well.

Let's add in a couple discard outlets if the form of Faithless Looting and Cathartic Reunion. Liliana of the Veil and Rix Maadi, the Dungeon Palace are okay as well. The typical 'tutor things into your graveyard' cards - Buried Alive, Entomb, and Gamble - are pretty good too. Perhaps the most exciting piece of this deck are the support cards that make your Bladewings even more busted: Flayer of the Hatebound and Where Ancients Tread in particular. Warstorm Surge and Pandemonium are other options, but I think Where Ancients Tread hits a sweetspot of mana efficiency and power.

With all that said, this is where I ended up. I can't wait to take this deck for a spin at GPNJ later this month, and I imagine that this will be my new project for the foreseeable future. If you've got any suggestions or questions, please send them my way! I'll be thrilled to try to make this a more streamlined, dragon reanimating machine.