The format has changed a lot since I first started paying attention, and largely for the better. Storm and Infect were too fast for the majority of decks to keep pace with. The lifegain provided by Glimmerpost made Cloudpost far too resilient against non-Infect aggressive strategies. Temporal Fissure locks backed up by anemic beatdown was a miserable play pattern. For each card on the banned list, there are similar examples of large blocks of strategies being rendered largely unplayable.
But what about contemporary Pauper? I still follow the format, but I stopped seriously playing about two years ago at this point. I've long been of the opinion that contemporary Pauper is not a particularly healthy format, but I've never really discussed it in a long-form format. So here goes.
What Does Healthy Mean?
Rather than starting with the things that have pushed me away from the format, I want to start with what, in my mind, are measures of a healthy format. I tried for awhile to come up with some cute heuristics - things like the viability of Mono-Black Midrange or something similar. Here's the thing, it all boils down to this:
Interaction should matter. The core of the format should not revolve around trying to avoid engaging with your opponent in any way.
Is This Format Interactive?
When you take a glance at the overall metagame, I think it's reasonable to say that everything is fine. There's plenty of viable decks and a reasonable amount of counterplay, so everything's fine, right? Tron is the most represented deck - that's a control deck, so that's interactive. Blue tempo decks are represented, that's good as long as they aren't overbearing. The Boros monarch decks are midrangey, and you've got Burn, Stompy, Affinity, and Bogles as beatdown decks. There's even Elves as a combo strategy. So what's the problem?
Here's my question: how many of these decks actually care about what their opponents are doing in any substantial way?
The bulk of the interaction in Tron decks is in the form of Stonehorn Dignitary and effects like Moment's Peace and Prismatic Strands. There are a handful of counterspells, but those are mostly intended to protect your flickers from getting sniped by spot removal. Dinrova Horror is a kind of interaction, but is primarily a combo piece to help lock opponents out of the game with Ghostly Flicker. Does locking your opponent out of their combat step count as interaction?
The Blue tempo strategies and Boros midrange are certainly interactive, though it looks like the Boros deck is presently leaning an awful lot on Prismatic Strands.
Sure, the Burn decks playing Searing Blaze. You even have Weather the Storm to try to beat them. The matchup against Spellstutter Sprite decks can be rather intricate. But calling the Pauper versions of these decks interactive is incredibly generous. The deck largely doesn't even depend on the combat step, at least in part due to the prevalence of Stonehorn Dignitary and Fogs.
Look at some of the Stompy, Bogles, and Affinity lists. Besides their explosive potential to win games before opponents get set up, how many ways to these decks have to dodge common forms of interaction? All of these decks have ways to shut off edicts. They all have ways to dodge blockers or win outside of combat. They all have ways to make removal spells embarrassing. All while presenting a very fast clock with resilient threats. How are you supposed to keep pace with all of these varied strategies without resorting to locking them out of combat?
All in all, I'd say that the overwhelming majority of decks are looking to do some combination of racing and ignoring opposing strategies while minimizing interaction points. I know there are plenty of people who enjoy these types of games. I'll also fully admit my bias and preference for formats where slow, interactive Blue decks are premier strategies. Regardless of your preference, I think it's worth asking whether this is the healthiest place for the format to be.
Root Cause?
Metagames are complicated ecosystems, and I'm not going to pretend to know what the best way to modify them is. The whole thing is a weird Jenga tower of interdependent pieces. Adding or removing a card to that ecosystem can have enormous and unexpected consequences. That said, here are a few of the issues I see:
Control decks are narrow and non-interactive. When the primary focus of control strategies is to lock opponents out of the game with Stonehorn Dignitary and Ghostly Flicker backed up by Moment's Peace and Prismatic Strands, that - to me - indicates that there is an underlying issue. The fact that there are no other serious control decks is also indicative of a problem.
Linear decks are far too explosive and resilient. Decks like Stompy, Affinity, Burn, and Bogles have existed since I've been playing the format. They've always been fine choices. They didn't always have cards like Burning-Tree Emissary, Ethereal Armor, and Thermoalchemist. The raw efficiency of these strategies combined with how diverse they all are puts an enormous amount of strain on 'fair' decks. Matchups become more about whether or not the answers you brought line up in a macro-sense and less about the choices you make in them. There are no generically good removal spells or sweepers. Even if you play a bunch of spot removal, it's not guaranteed to be efficient enough or line up well. That combination of things pushes players towards Fogs as a primary means of interaction.
Ghostly Flicker is bad for the format. I love this card and all the cute tricks it can do. I've flickered more Prophetic Prisms, Bojuka Bogs, and Serrated Arrows than I can reasonably count. The combination of Ghostly Flicker, Mnemonic Wall, and Capsize locks out all manner of strategies that could otherwise contend with Tron decks. There is can never be anything that's better at going to the late game than Ghostly Flicker decks that can generate infinite resources. Anything that tries to go later will get devoured by the linear strategies. The lack of variety in endgame for control decks is a bad thing for the format.
Monarch cards put a huge strain on the format. I've generally enjoyed the games that I play with Monarch cards in Pauper. That said, I think it's worth considering the two negative effects they can have on the format. First, control strategies are embarrassing against Monarch cards. Either you have a counterspell for every Monarch card over the course of a game, or you have to ignore their entire strategy and go way bigger with Ghostly Flickers. Against aggressive decks, you're encouraged to play a bunch of Prismatic Strands in conjunction with your Monarch cards to stabilize and maintain Monarch status against the explosive linear decks.
Edicts are enormously high variance. Depending on the matchup and how your draws line up, Edicts range from 'literally the only effect that gets you out of a bad situation' to 'utterly blank piece of cardboard'. They are one of the best ways to snipe high toughness creatures without getting got by hexproof or Vines of the Vastwood. But if your opponent has Young Wolf, Cartouche of Solidarity, or Flayer Husk, your edict is all but blank. For a long time, edicts were an important part of the ecosystem of Pauper removal spells. In recent years, they've incidentally lost a lot of their power and I'm not sure the format is better off for it.
Wrapping Up
So what's the point? I think I've done a reasonable job of outlining the things that have driven me away from the format. It's gotten a lot faster and - in my mind at least - less interactive than it used to be. Plenty of people will like the format as it is today better. There's nothing wrong with that. As long as people are playing and enjoying the format, it doesn't have to cater towards me in particular.
That said, I miss the days of Tron decks playing a bunch of Magma Sprays and Lightning Bolts. The games felt much more dynamic to me, and trying to figure out how to best line up your combination of removal and countermagic against Delver and Stompy decks is some of the most fun I've ever had playing Magic.
The format has changed a lot in recent years, and I think the discussion about whether the end result is better or worse than where we started is one that's worth having. I just wanted to take an opportunity to reflect on those changes as I see them and highlight some of the things that have made me less enthusiastic about the format.
No comments:
Post a Comment