Friday, January 29, 2021

Flickering Noodle Serpents for Fun and Profit

 I've been trying to make Blue-White control work in Commander for a very long time. I've played with Ephara plus tokens and/or Planeswalkers. I've shifted to Raff with Planeswalkers, using Proteus Staff to find Deepglow Skate - the only other creature - to emblem up immediately. I've seen lots of interesting takes on Brago over the years, but none of them really captured my imagination because I don't like beating down.

Enter Yorion. This noodle serpent is everything that I ever wanted Brago to be, and I'm kind of astonished at how little traction it seems to have gotten in the months since Ikoria has been printed. Maybe it's burnout from Yorion being so good in other formats? I don't really know. What I do know is that I've held off on taking a look at Yorion because I haven't been super excited about Magic in awhile, but here we are.

So what does Yorion do that makes it so exciting? Fundamentally, it does a lot of the same things that Brago does. The most straightforward thing is that you can rebuy 'enters the battlefield' effects of various baubles and creatures. The second thing is that you can untap key non-land permanents like mana rocks. Last, you can reset things like Sagas or Planeswalkers.

Here's the thing. Yorion is a very different beast from Brago for several reasons, all related to Yorion being an 'enters the battlefield' ability rather than triggering off of combat damage. Critically, Yorion pairs with instant-speed flicker effects to do a number of really interesting things. Let's break those down.

First, you can use Yorion on opponent's turns as well as yours. That means that you can get a bunch of Yorion triggers per turn cycle instead of just one or two. That means that you can draw extra cards off of your Prophetic Prisms and Wall of Omens. Not only that, it means you can use your mana rocks on your turn, untap them on your end step, and repeat on each players' turn. That's a ton of extra cards and mana that you can leverage to pull ahead, stay ahead, and close out the game rapidly.

Second, you can use Yorion in conjunction with instant-speed flickers to protect your permanents from opposing sweepers or spot removal. I generally have an aversion to leaning too heavily on mana rocks because they get caught up in sweepers. Pairing them with Yorion means that you've got a board presence that generates a bunch of free cards and mana while also giving you some built-in ability to protect yourself from getting completely blown out by cards like Vandalblast and Austere Command.

Finally, you can use Yorion in conjunction with creatures like Restoration Angel to guarantee that you get to flicker up to your entire board every single turn without investing additional resources. Once you're at that point, you just need to manage your hand so you have a bunch of protection and leverage your extra cards and mana to close the game out.

In my mind, this is sort of a perfect storm of things that makes Yorion really fun to think about but gives the noodle serpent a really high likelihood of being really overbearing at most tables. You're incentivized to play a bunch of mana rocks - some of the more degenerate cards in the format anyway - and you can get extra use out of those to get even further ahead. Once you're ahead, it's relatively hard to break up Yorion loops for any considerable period of time, and those Yorion loops will eventually just bury the table in resources.

Let's break down the key pieces.

Flicker Effects

We're looking for things that function at instant-speed. Depending on what power level you're shooting for, there's a number of ways to make repeatable loops with the likes of Eldrazi Displacer, Deadeye Navigator, or even Archaeomancer plus Ghostly Flicker.

You can use effects like Charming Prince or Astral Drift that flicker and return Yorion at the end of your turn - you're just going to want to do everything you can to use them before your opponents leave their second main phase so that Yorion returns on that end step. It's important to note here that if Yorion enters the battlefield on an end step, all the permanents you flicker will be gone until the end step of the following turn.

For me, I'd rather stay away from the repeatable flickers and focus on instants and sorceries in the hopes that it helps strike the right balance of powerful but not overbearing. That means I'm looking for things like Cloudshift, Ephemerate, Essence Flux, and Restoration Angel. The one mana ones are probably worth running in almost any build, the real break point is going to be where you draw the line on two- and three-mana flickers like Flicker of Fate, Teferi's Time Twist, Ghostly Flicker, and Displace.

Mana Rocks

The key here is that you're looking first and foremost for mana rocks that enter the battlefield untapped so that you net mana when you flicker them. The second thing you're looking for is ones that have extra enters the battlefield effects. The third thing you're looking for is rocks that generate colored mana so you can cast spells on opposing turns instead of just ending up with a ton of colorless mana you can't use.

Obviously the super busted rocks are great here. Mana Crypt and Sol Ring let you get super far ahead very quickly. The thing is, cards like Grim Monolith, Basalt Monolith, and Mana Vault are also super busted here because you can untap them for 'free.' I really like cheap rocks that make colored mana for this style of deck, so Azorius Signet, Arcane Signet, and Talisman of Progress seem great. I also like rocks that you can cash in later in the game like Mind Stone and Hedron Archive. Mana Geode and even Darksteel Relic seem just fine, since they generate colored mana and help bridge you into more expensive and more powerful rocks.

Then we get to some of the really interesting stuff. The card I'm singly most interested in for this deck is Coveted Jewel. It's absurd to flicker beacuse it draws cards and makes colored mana to cast those cards. Not only that, but Yorion helps stop your opponent from stealing it. Gilded Lotus is another fine card that's similar, though less powerful.

Something that I'm very excited about is the prospect of pairing cards like Mirrormade and Phyrexian Metamorph with this card to get even bigger. It's important to note that clones cannot copy things that enter the battlefield at the same time as they do, so beware blindly flickering your entire board.

There are non-mana rock effects that serve a similar purpose - the 'free' cards from Urza block like Cloud of Faeries, Treachery, and Peregrine Drake.

Cantrip Baubles

Prophetic Prism is emblematic of what I want to pair with Yorion. Cheap artifacts that help smooth your draw early and then pair with Yorion going late to keep your hand full of gas. There's lots of things that can fill this role depending on what the rest of your deck looks like. Arcum's Astrolabe and Wall of Omens are simple things that just draw cards. There are other options like Alchemist's Vial and Sleeper Dart that give you some additional utility. There's also things that give you a little more selection like Watcher for Tomorrow. You could even go super deep on something like Trinket Mage or Tribute Mage to help find additional baubles to cast turn after turn.

Bringing Together the Artifact Engine

Something that I'm really excited about is that there are a lot of really interesting ways to make the artifact engine go even harder. The biggest problem with leaning hard into artifacts is that when you draw extra cards on opposing turns, you're going to draw a bunch of sorcery speed effects that are going to clog up your hand.

Enter Shimmer Myr, Raff Capashen, and Vedalken Orrery. Now your baubles help you draw more rocks and baubles which you can immediately play and leverage to do even more stuff. All the while, Yorion gives you the ability to protect the board you're building. 




But that's not all. Let's add Mirrorworks to the mix. Now every time your artifacts blink back in, you can make copies of key pieces like Coveted Jewel. This is effectively a great way to ensure that you can leverage most of the extra mana you're generating to continuously build your board. Not only that, but if the tokens would ever become a liability, you can flicker them out of existence with Yorion.

ETB Answers

The next piece of the puzzle is a means of actually controlling the game. Obviously instants and counterspells are going to be important. Things like Swords to Plowshares and Path to Exile are still going to be great. Free and cheap counterspells are going to be exceptional as well, particularly ones that can fight against instant-speed responses to your blink effects.

That said, the way you really make sure that your opponents can't mount a reasonable offense is by using Yorion in conjunction with flexible or repeatable answers.

The kinds of things that I'm most interested in are the like of Spine of Ish Sah, Act of Authority, and Reality Acid. Oblivion Ring and Detention Sphere are interesting because you can do Faceless Butcher tricks with them, but I don't know how good that ends up being.

Another category of answer that I'm very interested in are auras like Spreading Seas, Darksteel Mutation, and Imprisoned in the Moon. These are interesting because Yorion can flicker them out and then back in onto a different permanent than they were enchanting before, meaning that you can shift targets as the game evolves.

The Manifest Engine

The last big piece, in my mind, is a really cool engine that one of my friends utilized in their Brago deck. Manifest cards are a great way to turn Brago and Yorion into huge bursts of mana and advantage. If you can manifest lands or expensive permanents and then flicker them out, you can end up really far ahead.

In particular, I'm interested in pairing Cloudform, Lightform, and Heliod's Pilgrim, since they not only flip a card back face up, but also net you another manifest each loop. Scroll of Fate is a great way to give you a little more control over what you end up flickering.

Furthermore, for when you hit instants and sorceries, you've got Primordial Mist to make sure that you can cast the spells that you exile with manifest cards.

Winning the Game

This is one of the big questions that control decks have to wrangle with in Commander. You've shut down your opponents and drawn a billion cards. How are you actually going to end the game? There's lots of ways to do it, and I honestly don't know what the thing that makes the most sense is. To me, the most obvious choices are things like Altar of the Brood and Triskelion, but I'm sure there's a very straightforward way to convert Yorion loops into a win off of Thassa's Oracle or something similar.


So there's my breakdown of why I think Yorion is super interesting, but likely to be super overbearing. It's a combination of rewarding degenerate cards, repetitive play patterns, and combinations that are exceedingly difficult to break up. I haven't figured out exactly how I want to build mine to balance the cool things that Yorion can do with the overbearing play patterns that it is capable of, but this is where I'll be figuring it out.