Sunday, March 14, 2021

Building Our 1v1 PokeCube

 In recent months, My wife and I have been having a lot of fun exploring what the Pokemon TCG has to offer. However, it didn't take long for us to start running into a familiar problem: constructed decks are hard to balance against one another, especially when the players have wildly different objectives and levels of experience. 

Generally speaking, limited is a great equalizer. The problem is that, on its face, Pokemon doesn't lend itself to limited play. Evolution is a really tough mechanic for limited card pools and the game needs a critical mass of card drawing and selection for games to be functional. These are things that you're unlikely to be able to resolve without an enormous sealed pool or many packs worth of drafting.


Enter Cube. The curated draft experience that has exploded over the last decade in MTG. It turns out that it's getting huge in Pokemon as well, with a number of incredible resources for those who are looking for a place to get started:


All of these resources are great for giving you a rundown to some of the solutions for parasitic evolution mechanics and some idea of where to start figuring out what kinds of cards to include and how many.


1v1 Draft


Here's the thing though - there's only two of us, which makes a traditional cube not particularly helpful. Fortunately our friend, squash86, has given us a template for a 1v1 cube experience with his Vintage cube. The gist is that it's a small set of cards (120) that you draft the entirety of every time. Packs are drafted face up so both players have perfect information about what's going on. This format introduces a few wrinkles that need to be considered. 


  • When both players see every card in every draft, you have to think hard about how many of certain kinds of effects should be available in the pool. 

  • Hate drafting is a real thing and is particularly problematic for Pokemon. What could feel worse than having your opponent hate your Stage 2 payoff out from under you? This is especially problematic if there are archetypes with low setup cost (big basics or stage 1s, for example)

  • When the cube is small, how much of it do you want to dedicate to things like energy fixing to smooth games out?


So here's where we're at. Our cube is currently 230 Singleton cards and is intended to be drafted one 10 card pack at a time. The first player will get picks 1, 4, and 5. The second player will get picks 2, 3, and 6. Then the remaining 4 cards are removed from the draft. The player who picks first alternates with every pack. I'm the end, you'll need to build a 60 card deck.


Here's what that's trying to accomplish: you'll get 30% of 230 cards (69) to build your deck. Presumably you'll need ~45 non-energy cards, which gives you about 24 cards that didn't need to pan out. I think that still gives you a little too much wiggle room for hate drafting, but it's a reasonable place to start. Certainly better than the alternative of players using 115 picks to break up one another's evolution lines and slowly plink each other with the dregs leftover.


The sequence of picks is also intended to make sure that people prioritize the things they need. Your opponent getting two picks in a row makes you think much harder about what you actually want with your first pick. When you get two picks in a row it's easier to make sure you're getting a cohesive plan.


The big thing that my wife wants to change outside of the draft is to play with rainbow basics. This is a concession to the size of the cube and card pools that players end up with. There’s only so many pokemon of a given type in the cube, and you’re not going to be able to take all of them and also get enough supporting cards to make something functional. By the same token, there’s not a ton of space in the cube for cards that fix energy types unless you cut more interesting cards to make space.


This change is absolutely enormous. It means that Machamp can be powered up by Volcanion or Virizion. It means that Blastoise can power up a Venusaur. Does it end up being balanced? I have absolutely no idea. But at least for the early phases of balancing the cube, it makes it easier to come up with decks that can jockey for weakness/resistance advantages while still being functional.


The Contents

So those are the mechanics. What about the actual contents? We have a couple goals. First, include Pokemon we like. That’s easy enough, but only time will tell if they are remotely balanced against one another. Second, support a variety of strategies. This one is tough because we don’t even really know what the breadth of strategies are. Third, to include a bunch of powerful cards from across the game’s history without creating non-games. The one big exemption is that my wife has decided that we will not be using modern EX, GX, or V pokemon in an effort to keep the HP and damage numbers relatively consistent across the cube.


In general, each type has one stage 2 line, one stage 1 line, and 3 basics. The stage 2 line is 2-2-3 (e.g. 2 Venusaur, 2 Ivysaur, 3 Bulbasaur). The stage 1 line is 2-2. Fairy doesn’t get its own line because there’s a limited cardpool and the type is being phased out. Dragon gets just Dragonite as a stage 2 line because I enjoy Dragonite. There are 4 eevees and one of each eeveelution. There’s no strong theme for any one type at this point - just a bunch of cards that we like the idea of.


Here's the current list.


Lessons Learned

We've drafted 3 or 4 times at this point and have learned a couple things about the cube in its current state and about particular cards.
  • There are too many rain dancers in this cube. Blastoise, Dragonair, Magnezone, and Hydreigon. This really needs to be reduced to something more manageable.
  • Po Town and similar effects are really important for non-stage 2 decks to keep pace.
  • We've probably leaned too hard into basics that set up rather than beat down. I'm not sure how to approach fixing this.
  • There are too many consistency cards in the cube right now relative to the number of players and the size of the pools they end up with.
  • Shuckle is not a reasonable card if there are going to be rain dancers in the cube. Needs to get cut immediately.

Goals for Revisions

Here's the short list of things that I want to keep at the forefront of my mind for the first round of revisions:
  • Straight up cut at least 10 cards with the goal of getting down to around 200 over a few revisions.
  • Replace some of the set up basics with attacking basics
  • Try to figure out what archetypical pokemon strategies are not accounted for in the cube. Is control/stall a thing? What does that look like?
  • Should we be favoring supporters over items to slow games down? Does that make play/draw less balanced? Or is getting the first evolution worth missing out on both the first supporter and first attack?

Cuts and Maybeboard

Here are some of the things that I'm thinking about cutting. Some to be replaced, others potentially not replaced.
  1. Exeggcute - this plays super well with all the cards that require discards, but feels kind of redundant to Training Court. Are two of this kind of effect necessary in such a small cube?
  2. Alolan Sandslashes feel kind of underpowered
  3. Lapras feels slow for what it does.
  4. Kyogre - redundant to other energy acceleration?
  5. Plusle - just worse than Minun? Probably better as an attacker of some kind.
  6. Mimikyu - it does set up and spread, but is kind of bad at both of those jobs.
  7. Mew - Maybe this gets better if we lean into stronger attacking basics? Right now it hasn't felt exciting.
  8. Cubone - We definitely underestimated the cost of taking two turns to get this attack off, even for one energy.
  9. Shuckle - this thing is disgusting and cannot exist alongside rain dancers. That kind of engine is way over what we're looking for.
  10. Gliscor - Generally feels like a weak evolution line, but is a way to status stall? I'm not sure what would replace it.
  11. Raichu - Feels weak? It's a lot of work to stall this way.
  12. Scramble Switch - We've got Float Stone and Fluffy Berry and Switch trainers. I can't imagine wanting this over other ACE Specs.
  13. Life Dew - Maybe I just haven't had the chance to draft a deck around this yet?
And here's the list of cards that I may want to try in future updates:
  1. Audino - Do the wave on a basic may be a good way to beat down, especially if we add more of Upper Energy and Twin Energy.
  2. Lucario - I kind of like Do the Wave as a Stage 1 attacking deck. There's some counter play from cards like Parallel City and it requires some commitment in terms of picking DCEs and ways to fill the bench highly.
  3. Raticate - is this a thing? I think I overvalue these effects because of my experience with MTG.
  4. Cursed Stone - Po Town and Crobats are huge for giving basic or stage 1 decks more reach against stage 2 decks. Maybe this is another card in that vein?
  5. Shedinja - Is this just a better Life Dew? It's easier to find and there's no way to shut off abilities right now.
  6. Shedinja - Maybe this pairs with Life Dew to make a deck that recycles those two cards? What's the stall end game though?
  7. Mr. Mime - The classic? Again, I'm just not sure what the end game is for a stall deck. I worry about making the plan too compact in terms of required picks as well.
  8. Cofagrigus - This is a way to recycle pokemon like Uxie that do things when you bench them, I guess?
  9. Articuno - I like the idea of this, but I'm fairly confident it's just not good.
  10. Cramorant - Splits the difference between spread and a reasonable basic attacker?
  11. Hawlucha - Okay setup pokemon, but also kind of attacks? Maybe.
  12. Zapdos - Hits super hard but makes you work for it? 
  13. Celebi - Reasonable attacker against rain dancers but also a set up pokemon for decks with many evolutions? This only works if we continue using rainbow basics.


Wrap Up

And that's where we're at. It's been an interesting project and we've had a lot of fun playing the games so far. That said, I think there's still a lot of refinement to be done here before everything is relatively balanced and there's a good diversity of approaches. I absolutely can't wait to bring this to our first gathering of friends post-quarantine and try to get a bunch of drafts in.