I have a special place in my heart for goofy, fiddly combo decks - especially ones that are non-deterministic. Things like various Eggs-flavored combo decks are exactly my favorite kind of thing to do in more competitive variants of Magic. One of the decks that set me on this path was a Warp World combo deck that was a transition between me playing 'cards I own' as a format and more focused decks.
The way that the Warp World deck worked is by trying to spin into an additional warp world plus extra permanents so that you get bigger and bigger each time. Cards like Izzet Chronomancer and Anarchist let you go again, while things like Wood Elves and Fists of Ironwood were the way that you pulled ahead on permanents. Eventually you'd kill your opponent by flipping over Galvanic Arc a couple of times.
This is pertinent because Modern Horizons 2 has created a new version of this deck in the modern format, and it's giving me some feels. That version of the deck relies on the cascade engine to flip into Glimpse of Tomorrow, but otherwise behaves in a very similar fashion. The goal is to spin into cards like Seasoned Pyromancer and Goblin Dark-Dwellers so that you can generate more permanents and keep the engine going.
All of that said, you don't build this kind of combo deck because it's good. You do it exactly because there are so many fiddly things to try to balance and ways that thing can go wrong. For anyone who wants to see the deck in progress in its current state,
just head here. For the rest of you, let's break this down into a couple of key ideas and see where we end up:
Consistently Finding a Warp World
The most important question is how you're going to consistently find your combo pieces. In this case, the least interchangeable one is a Warp World or Glimpse of Tomorrow. There are at least a handful of things that come to mind that I think are just a little too inconsistent. Things like Tolaria West and Spellseeker to find Glimpse along with As Foretold to cast it and various Eternal Witness effects to make sure you can rebuy it is one approach. You could also go with self-mill kinds of effects combined with Eternal Witnesses to try to find your pieces. But all of that feels a little too inconsistent. You have to play a bunch of cards that don't really contribute to your plan of generating more permanents just to stitch your engine together.
Instead, what I settled on was Codie, Vociferous Codex. With careful deck construction, this card lets you have your key combo piece effectively as your Commander and play more similarly to the cascade style of Warp World deck. As long as you aren't playing any other non-permanent spells - or at least in a particular range of mana values - Codie will always cascade into Glimpse of Tomorrow. We wanted our deck to be mostly permanents anyway, so that seems like a pretty straightforward direction to go in. The problem is that this approach only guarantees one Glimpse, and that's definitely not going to be enough to kill the table. We're going to need ways to get Glimpse of Tomorrow back into our deck and cascade again.
Getting Glimpses back into your deck is a straightforward proposition. What you want is things like Reclaim or Memory's Journey. But those are spells, not permanents. Having to rely on permanents takes us down the path of Vessel of Endless Rest, Mystic Sanctuary, and Nantuko Tracer. It should be noted that you need to hit one of this kind of effect on every iteration, otherwise you won't have another Glimpse to cascade into. The math on how many of these you need to consistently do that is going to change based on how many permanents you can get onto the battlefield before you go for your Codie cascade.
- Vessel of Endless Rest
- Mystic Sanctuary
- Nantuko Tracer
- Loaming Shaman
- Biblioplex Assistant
- Bloodwater Entity
- Reito Lantern
- Conjurer's Bauble
- Elixir of Immortality
It's also worth noting that your options open up depending on how much mana you can generate after each cascade. Something like Trinket Mage can find cheap mana rocks or a conjurer's bauble. Imperial Recruiter or Recruiter of the Guard could find creature-based ways to solve this problem. Trophy Mage can find Vessel of Endless Rest. The point is that, even if there aren't a ton of great effects that solve this problem, there are secondary ways to increase your density that might also be able to find other combo cards.
Speaking of other combo cards, we've only talked about how to put your Glimpse back, not how you're actually going to cascade into it again. I think the easiest way to do this is actually just to plan on casting Codie again every iteration. This means that you're hoping to hit nine mana on your first iteration - 5 to recast Codie and 4 to active - and an additional two mana on each spin. That should happen relatively naturally as a result of spinning into more and more permanents, but it's still something to be mindful of.
The other missing piece is that Codie is going to need haste. This is a similar problem to getting Glimpses back into your deck in that there are a number of interesting ways of solving it, but the backup plans and how they can tie into also generating more permanents is also interesting. Things that globally grant haste are probably the most preferable solution, since that means your opponents have to have a counterspell for Codie rather than responding to your Lightning Greaves with a removal spell. But the additional value of having potential Stoneforge Mystic targets as ways to continue comboing off should not be ignored. Here's some things I'm considering:
- Lightning Greaves
- Fires of Yavimaya
- Rhythm of the Wild
- Temur Ascendancy
- Arlinn Kord
- Ashling's Prerogative
- Hanweir Battlements
- Slayers' Stronghold
The good news is that, as long as you consistently hit these three pieces - mana, haste, and recycling - you get to keep going. The hard part is balancing these three components with the extra permanents you need to get bigger and building in redundancy to protect against fizzling.
I Need More
Doesn't matter what it is. Mana, permanents, spells to cast - this deck needs more of all of them so that you can continuously get bigger and bigger spins. You'll find a way to win eventually.
Cards that generate additional permanents are the easiest place to start - bonus points for ones that generate also generate more mana. In my mind, that easily narrows down to creatures that find lands and creatures that make treasures. Treasure in particular is an exciting thig to push, because it is either more permanents or more mana, whichever you need at the time. But we can lean into other engines also. Anything that generates permanents based on other permanents is a big deal here. Avenger of Zendikar and Tireless Tracker are great examples of things that can get out of control very quickly. Field of the Dead is another way to do it in your mana base. Chancellor of the Forge is a great way to get exponentially bigger once you have one of these other engines online.
Mana is a slightly harder question. Sure, eventually you'll hit enough lands to be effectively self-sufficient, but getting there is difficult. Cards like Tireless Provisioner, Lotus Cobra, and Omnath, Locus of Creation are a good place to start since they play well with all of the landfall token generation. It's worth noting here that clones aren't going to do you any good because they can't copy things that enter the battlefield at the same time as them. The backup plan is to spin into big mana rocks and mana multipliers. Stuff like Gilded Lotus and Chromatic Orrery or Nyxbloom Ancient and Mirari's Wake.
With all the tokens going on, you'd better believe that Parallel Lives and Anointed Precession are absolutely out of control. The real question is whether they're necessary or win-more.
But How Do I Win?
This is a super interesting question, because it's not necessarily as straightforward as you think. One way to win is to just spin until you have a lethal, hasty board. But remember that you're going to be not-so-slowly leeching permanents out of your deck. Are you going to hit a critical mass before you run out of cards in your library? Will you get a chance to attack before dying to draw triggers on cards like Omnath, Locus of Creation?
It's fairly trivial to build your deck such that continuing to spin incidentally kills your opponents. Omnath will do it in four point chunks. Terror of the Peaks or Warstorm Surge will certainly do it. Valakut the Molten Pinnacle or Stensia Bloodhall are both cheeky ways to get it done. The real question is how compact or redundant with your other goals you can get the win condition to be while still being resilient enough to interaction.
If incidental triggers is plan, then I just need to be able to continuously spin in response to any draw triggers that might kill me. Enter rescue creatures. Things like Whitemane Lion or Fleetfoot Panther can bounce itself to your hand and guarantee you at least one spin for your entire deck. I say at least one because the Codie trigger will resolve before the creature, meaning that your rescue creature will be stranded on the stack when your next round of draw triggers go on. Alchemist's Refuge or Winding Canyons could give you even more spins, but I'm not sure how necessary that's going to be.
Here's where I've ended up on this deck for the time being. I think it's far from perfect and needs a lot of work to consistently do anything. That said, I don't know how much more work I'm going to do on this particular variant. I don't think deck is particularly friendly for casual tables - it's a fiddly combo deck with lots of onerous counting and shuffling and triggers that have to be carefully managed. Maybe I'll goldfish a couple games and tweak some of the numbers, but that's likely to be the extent of it.
What this deck does really well is present a really interesting deckbuilding exercise and create some really interesting questions. Are there other ways to leverage this kind of Codie engine? Maybe you can play all the cycling creatures and always hit Living End? Resurgent Belief? Inevitable Betrayal? Permanent-based Codie decks that recycle key low mana value spells is an interesting concept that I'm sure I'll revisit in the future.