Friday, September 9, 2022

Let's Talk About Pauper

The last two weeks or so has been one of those periods where I dive back into the format. One thing that I can't overstate is how different the format is - largely unrecognizeable from what it used to be, at least from my perspective. In and of itself, that's neither good nor bad. I just worry that changes by degrees are harder to notice if you're saturated in the format, and wonder at what point a conversation needs to be had about what the format's identity is supposed to be. What does "healthy" mean, where's the line on power, and what are the things that are constraining the format?

So what is this supposed to be. It's a writeup that no one asked for about what the current format, post initiative, feels like to someone who has played a lot historically, but is relatively new to the current iteration of things. 

To what end? I don't really know. I'm no one, and there's no reason for anyone to take these thoughts seriously. I think it's mostly just me getting some thoughts off of my desk, so to speak, but maybe there's something useful in my ramblings. 

Monarch and Initiative

The new excitement. I, personally, have never been a fan of the monarch as a mechanic is two-player formats. That said, I don't think that monarch was ever toxic to the point of needing action taken against it. Sure, it encouraged some play patterns where you turtle up with Palace Sentinels and Prismatic Strands, but the format was trending in that direction anyway given how efficient and varied the aggressive decks have become.

However, I think things are different with initiative. I honestly don't know that these things are really over the line on power. The thing is, we've hit a density of four-mana effects that make non-interactable emblems that enables people to play Dark Ritual and Lotus Petal to power them out as early as possible. I think this creates a lot of perverse incentives and toxic play patterns. Honest, fair decks will struggle to exist in a format where this is part of the baseline. I think this is likely to push the format even further into decks that are either piles of rate and/or trying to be as non-interactive as possible.

The one upside I see to initiative is that it gives all these Ephemerate and Ghostly Flicker decks a way to actually end the game in a timely fashion. Fundamentally though, I think the density of these effects and the way their existence constrains the rest of the format begs a question: are these going to be the identity of the format moving forward?

Free Spells

Pauper has storied history of free spells eventually hitting a point where they are unhealthy. Frantic Search, Invigorate, Cloud of Faeries, Gush, Daze, and Gitaxian Probe are all examples of cards that are wildly powerful relative to the rest of the format. Given what the format looks like today, there's a new batch of free cards for which I have to ask - are these still contributing to play patterns that are fun or healthy?

Let's start with Mutagenic Growth and Manamorphose. These are the cards that are currently powering the Mono-Red Kiln Fiend decks. These free spells, combined with the high density of pseudo-Prowess creatures and Temur Battle Rage, are consistently capable of killing players on turn three and four through interaction. 

Invigorate and Gitaxian Probe were already banned for enablings things like this, and I just don't feel like Mutagenic Growth and Manamorphose are that different anymore. We already hit the point years ago that control decks leaned on Stonehorn Dignitary and Fog over removal spells because of how efficienct and diverse the threats in Pauper are. Now we've hit a point where you can consistently die before Stonehorn is even castable. 

Fundamentally, the existence of a deck this consistently fast is an enormous constraint on what kinds of decks are playable, and forces the format down to the decks with the most efficient interaction. There is no going over the top because there is no time.

Last, let's briefly talk about Lotus Petal. Traditionally, Lotus Petal shows up in decks that are up to no good. These have typically been combo decks that fluctuate between powerful, but fragile and format-defining based on the availalbe payoffs. In the current format, that's not really true anymore. Thanks to initiative, we're now starting to see fair decks use Lotus Petal as a way to get a turn faster - to sneak haymakers under Counterspell or get out ahead of Kiln Fiend. Honestly, given the blistering speed of games, I also think it's worth considering whether the only reason we haven't seen more experimentation with Lotus Petal is because of its price online.

None of these cards are generally in decks where people are trying to do something fair. And all of them are likely to continue showing up in increasingly problematic decks in the future.

The Rest

To be clear, I don't necessarily believe that any of the things outlined above are necessarily overbearing in terms of raw power or metagame portion. That said, I think Monarch, Initiative, and free spells ask a core question about what the format's identity is supposed to be. These are the things that serious constraints on what kinds of decks can be played because of the specificity of their demands and the severity of the consequences for failing to meet them. If you can't interact with or overpower them early, your deck is not playable. 

Personally, I don't like these constraints and I'd be interested to see what the format looks like without these format-defining pressures before considering serious action on anything else. Right now, games feel like they center around turns two through four. What happens if there's more space to go over the top? Are there Fangren Marauder or cascade decks that can overpower the current status quo, but are boxed out by Kiln Fiends and turbo emblems?

The alternative is setting a new baseline for acceptable power, at which point I think we should probably consider whether cards can be unbanned now that standards have changed. Realistically though, the overwhelming majority of the banned list is dedicated to things that are traditionally unfair (free spells, storm) or decks that are still overbearingly powerful today (affinity, blue tempo). What does that leave? I guess Cloudpost, Bonder's Ornament, and Prophetic Prism? I'm not sure those cards make anything better, but Cloudpost can't be worth the risk.

Regardless, it feels like the format is at a crossroads of sorts, and a decision needs to be made about what it's going to be. Is it a format that soft rotates as s high powered cards and mechanics are printed directly into the format? Are we going to do anything about the archetypes and shells that consistently make the best use all of the new toys? Is there a general philosophy on what a "healthy" format looks like or at what point a card, archetype, or mechanic is too format warping or toxic? Does that change if something is analagous to something that's already been banned for enabling similar problems or play patterns?

Personally, I'd want to go nuclear. Kill the cards that put harsh constraints on the format, knock the piles of raw rate down that have sat at the top of the metagame down a peg, and try to bring back a world where honest decks are playable. Would it fix anything? I have no idea.

One thing I know for sure is that I don't envy the people who have to answer these questions, because people are going to be mad no matter what.  As for me, I'm just going to comfortably settle into my role of playing boomer decks that have become wildly outclassed.


Saturday, December 18, 2021

Codie Cascade Combo

I have a special place in my heart for goofy, fiddly combo decks - especially ones that are non-deterministic. Things like various Eggs-flavored combo decks are exactly my favorite kind of thing to do in more competitive variants of Magic. One of the decks that set me on this path was a Warp World combo deck that was a transition between me playing 'cards I own' as a format and more focused decks.

The way that the Warp World deck worked is by trying to spin into an additional warp world plus extra permanents so that you get bigger and bigger each time. Cards like Izzet Chronomancer and Anarchist let you go again, while things like Wood Elves and Fists of Ironwood were the way that you pulled ahead on permanents. Eventually you'd kill your opponent by flipping over Galvanic Arc a couple of times.


This is pertinent because Modern Horizons 2 has created a new version of this deck in the modern format, and it's giving me some feels. That version of the deck relies on the cascade engine to flip into Glimpse of Tomorrow, but otherwise behaves in a very similar fashion. The goal is to spin into cards like Seasoned Pyromancer and Goblin Dark-Dwellers so that you can generate more permanents and keep the engine going.




Seeing this kind of engine again is giving me a huge feeling of nostalgia for the Warp World deck of my childhood and has me wondering if it can be built in Commander. There are a number of reasons that this should be exceedingly difficult to accomplish in a 100-card, singleton format. First, it's much harder to maintain the appopriate density of key effects because there may not be enough of them. Second, even if the ratios are right, there are still more combinations that result in fizzling. Third, you have to find ways to continuously recycle some combination of Glimpse of Tomorrow and Warp World, since those are the only two versions of this kind of effect. Fourth, you have to generate a much bigger base of permanents before you can actually become deterministic - not only that, but it's harder to do so without fizzling because of the previous problems.

All of that said, you don't build this kind of combo deck because it's good. You do it exactly because there are so many fiddly things to try to balance and ways that thing can go wrong. For anyone who wants to see the deck in progress in its current state, just head here. For the rest of you, let's break this down into a couple of key ideas and see where we end up:

Consistently Finding a Warp World

The most important question is how you're going to consistently find your combo pieces. In this case, the least interchangeable one is a Warp World or Glimpse of Tomorrow. There are at least a handful of things that come to mind that I think are just a little too inconsistent. Things like Tolaria West and Spellseeker to find Glimpse along with As Foretold to cast it and various Eternal Witness effects to make sure you can rebuy it is one approach. You could also go with self-mill kinds of effects combined with Eternal Witnesses to try to find your pieces. But all of that feels a little too inconsistent. You have to play a bunch of cards that don't really contribute to your plan of generating more permanents just to stitch your engine together.

Instead, what I settled on was Codie, Vociferous Codex. With careful deck construction, this card lets you have your key combo piece effectively as your Commander and play more similarly to the cascade style of Warp World deck. As long as you aren't playing any other non-permanent spells - or at least in a particular range of mana values - Codie will always cascade into Glimpse of Tomorrow. We wanted our deck to be mostly permanents anyway, so that seems like a pretty straightforward direction to go in. The problem is that this approach only guarantees one Glimpse, and that's definitely not going to be enough to kill the table. We're going to need ways to get Glimpse of Tomorrow back into our deck and cascade again.

Getting Glimpses back into your deck is a straightforward proposition. What you want is things like Reclaim or Memory's Journey. But those are spells, not permanents. Having to rely on permanents takes us down the path of Vessel of Endless Rest, Mystic Sanctuary, and Nantuko Tracer. It should be noted that you need to hit one of this kind of effect on every iteration, otherwise you won't have another Glimpse to cascade into. The math on how many of these you need to consistently do that is going to change based on how many permanents you can get onto the battlefield before you go for your Codie cascade.
  • Vessel of Endless Rest
  • Mystic Sanctuary
  • Nantuko Tracer
  • Loaming Shaman
  • Biblioplex Assistant
  • Bloodwater Entity
  • Reito Lantern
  • Conjurer's Bauble
  • Elixir of Immortality
It's also worth noting that your options open up depending on how much mana you can generate after each cascade. Something like Trinket Mage can find cheap mana rocks or a conjurer's bauble. Imperial Recruiter or Recruiter of the Guard could find creature-based ways to solve this problem. Trophy Mage can find Vessel of Endless Rest. The point is that, even if there aren't a ton of great effects that solve this problem, there are secondary ways to increase your density that might also be able to find other combo cards.

Speaking of other combo cards, we've only talked about how to put your Glimpse back, not how you're actually going to cascade into it again. I think the easiest way to do this is actually just to plan on casting Codie again every iteration. This means that you're hoping to hit nine mana on your first iteration - 5 to recast Codie and 4 to active - and an additional two mana on each spin. That should happen relatively naturally as a result of spinning into more and more permanents, but it's still something to be mindful of.

The other missing piece is that Codie is going to need haste. This is a similar problem to getting Glimpses back into your deck in that there are a number of interesting ways of solving it, but the backup plans and how they can tie into also generating more permanents is also interesting. Things that globally grant haste are probably the most preferable solution, since that means your opponents have to have a counterspell for Codie rather than responding to your Lightning Greaves with a removal spell. But the additional value of having potential Stoneforge Mystic targets as ways to continue comboing off should not be ignored. Here's some things I'm considering:
  • Lightning Greaves
  • Fires of Yavimaya
  • Rhythm of the Wild
  • Temur Ascendancy
  • Arlinn Kord
  • Ashling's Prerogative
  • Hanweir Battlements
  • Slayers' Stronghold
The good news is that, as long as you consistently hit these three pieces - mana, haste, and recycling - you get to keep going. The hard part is balancing these three components with the extra permanents you need to get bigger and building in redundancy to protect against fizzling.

I Need More

Doesn't matter what it is. Mana, permanents, spells to cast - this deck needs more of all of them so that you can continuously get bigger and bigger spins. You'll find a way to win eventually.

Cards that generate additional permanents are the easiest place to start - bonus points for ones that generate also generate more mana. In my mind, that easily narrows down to creatures that find lands and creatures that make treasures. Treasure in particular is an exciting thig to push, because it is either more permanents or more mana, whichever you need at the time. But we can lean into other engines also. Anything that generates permanents based on other permanents is a big deal here. Avenger of Zendikar and Tireless Tracker are great examples of things that can get out of control very quickly. Field of the Dead is another way to do it in your mana base. Chancellor of the Forge is a great way to get exponentially bigger once you have one of these other engines online.



Mana is a slightly harder question. Sure, eventually you'll hit enough lands to be effectively self-sufficient, but getting there is difficult. Cards like Tireless Provisioner, Lotus Cobra, and Omnath, Locus of Creation are a good place to start since they play well with all of the landfall token generation. It's worth noting here that clones aren't going to do you any good because they can't copy things that enter the battlefield at the same time as them. The backup plan is to spin into big mana rocks and mana multipliers. Stuff like Gilded Lotus and Chromatic Orrery or Nyxbloom Ancient and Mirari's Wake.




With all the tokens going on, you'd better believe that Parallel Lives and Anointed Precession are absolutely out of control. The real question is whether they're necessary or win-more.

But How Do I Win?

This is a super interesting question, because it's not necessarily as straightforward as you think. One way to win is to just spin until you have a lethal, hasty board. But remember that you're going to be not-so-slowly leeching permanents out of your deck. Are you going to hit a critical mass before you run out of cards in your library? Will you get a chance to attack before dying to draw triggers on cards like Omnath, Locus of Creation?

It's fairly trivial to build your deck such that continuing to spin incidentally kills your opponents. Omnath will do it in four point chunks. Terror of the Peaks or Warstorm Surge will certainly do it. Valakut the Molten Pinnacle or Stensia Bloodhall are both cheeky ways to get it done. The real question is how compact or redundant with your other goals you can get the win condition to be while still being resilient enough to interaction.

If incidental triggers is plan, then I just need to be able to continuously spin in response to any draw triggers that might kill me. Enter rescue creatures. Things like Whitemane Lion or Fleetfoot Panther can bounce itself to your hand and guarantee you at least one spin for your entire deck. I say at least one because the Codie trigger will resolve before the creature, meaning that your rescue creature will be stranded on the stack when your next round of draw triggers go on. Alchemist's Refuge or Winding Canyons could give you even more spins, but I'm not sure how necessary that's going to be.




Wrapping Up   

Here's where I've ended up on this deck for the time being. I think it's far from perfect and needs a lot of work to consistently do anything. That said, I don't know how much more work I'm going to do on this particular variant. I don't think deck is particularly friendly for casual tables - it's a fiddly combo deck with lots of onerous counting and shuffling and triggers that have to be carefully managed. Maybe I'll goldfish a couple games and tweak some of the numbers, but that's likely to be the extent of it.

What this deck does really well is present a really interesting deckbuilding exercise and create some really interesting questions. Are there other ways to leverage this kind of Codie engine? Maybe you can play all the cycling creatures and always hit Living End? Resurgent Belief? Inevitable Betrayal? Permanent-based Codie decks that recycle key low mana value spells is an interesting concept that I'm sure I'll revisit in the future.


Sunday, March 14, 2021

Building Our 1v1 PokeCube

 In recent months, My wife and I have been having a lot of fun exploring what the Pokemon TCG has to offer. However, it didn't take long for us to start running into a familiar problem: constructed decks are hard to balance against one another, especially when the players have wildly different objectives and levels of experience. 

Generally speaking, limited is a great equalizer. The problem is that, on its face, Pokemon doesn't lend itself to limited play. Evolution is a really tough mechanic for limited card pools and the game needs a critical mass of card drawing and selection for games to be functional. These are things that you're unlikely to be able to resolve without an enormous sealed pool or many packs worth of drafting.


Enter Cube. The curated draft experience that has exploded over the last decade in MTG. It turns out that it's getting huge in Pokemon as well, with a number of incredible resources for those who are looking for a place to get started:


All of these resources are great for giving you a rundown to some of the solutions for parasitic evolution mechanics and some idea of where to start figuring out what kinds of cards to include and how many.


1v1 Draft


Here's the thing though - there's only two of us, which makes a traditional cube not particularly helpful. Fortunately our friend, squash86, has given us a template for a 1v1 cube experience with his Vintage cube. The gist is that it's a small set of cards (120) that you draft the entirety of every time. Packs are drafted face up so both players have perfect information about what's going on. This format introduces a few wrinkles that need to be considered. 


  • When both players see every card in every draft, you have to think hard about how many of certain kinds of effects should be available in the pool. 

  • Hate drafting is a real thing and is particularly problematic for Pokemon. What could feel worse than having your opponent hate your Stage 2 payoff out from under you? This is especially problematic if there are archetypes with low setup cost (big basics or stage 1s, for example)

  • When the cube is small, how much of it do you want to dedicate to things like energy fixing to smooth games out?


So here's where we're at. Our cube is currently 230 Singleton cards and is intended to be drafted one 10 card pack at a time. The first player will get picks 1, 4, and 5. The second player will get picks 2, 3, and 6. Then the remaining 4 cards are removed from the draft. The player who picks first alternates with every pack. I'm the end, you'll need to build a 60 card deck.


Here's what that's trying to accomplish: you'll get 30% of 230 cards (69) to build your deck. Presumably you'll need ~45 non-energy cards, which gives you about 24 cards that didn't need to pan out. I think that still gives you a little too much wiggle room for hate drafting, but it's a reasonable place to start. Certainly better than the alternative of players using 115 picks to break up one another's evolution lines and slowly plink each other with the dregs leftover.


The sequence of picks is also intended to make sure that people prioritize the things they need. Your opponent getting two picks in a row makes you think much harder about what you actually want with your first pick. When you get two picks in a row it's easier to make sure you're getting a cohesive plan.


The big thing that my wife wants to change outside of the draft is to play with rainbow basics. This is a concession to the size of the cube and card pools that players end up with. There’s only so many pokemon of a given type in the cube, and you’re not going to be able to take all of them and also get enough supporting cards to make something functional. By the same token, there’s not a ton of space in the cube for cards that fix energy types unless you cut more interesting cards to make space.


This change is absolutely enormous. It means that Machamp can be powered up by Volcanion or Virizion. It means that Blastoise can power up a Venusaur. Does it end up being balanced? I have absolutely no idea. But at least for the early phases of balancing the cube, it makes it easier to come up with decks that can jockey for weakness/resistance advantages while still being functional.


The Contents

So those are the mechanics. What about the actual contents? We have a couple goals. First, include Pokemon we like. That’s easy enough, but only time will tell if they are remotely balanced against one another. Second, support a variety of strategies. This one is tough because we don’t even really know what the breadth of strategies are. Third, to include a bunch of powerful cards from across the game’s history without creating non-games. The one big exemption is that my wife has decided that we will not be using modern EX, GX, or V pokemon in an effort to keep the HP and damage numbers relatively consistent across the cube.


In general, each type has one stage 2 line, one stage 1 line, and 3 basics. The stage 2 line is 2-2-3 (e.g. 2 Venusaur, 2 Ivysaur, 3 Bulbasaur). The stage 1 line is 2-2. Fairy doesn’t get its own line because there’s a limited cardpool and the type is being phased out. Dragon gets just Dragonite as a stage 2 line because I enjoy Dragonite. There are 4 eevees and one of each eeveelution. There’s no strong theme for any one type at this point - just a bunch of cards that we like the idea of.


Here's the current list.


Lessons Learned

We've drafted 3 or 4 times at this point and have learned a couple things about the cube in its current state and about particular cards.
  • There are too many rain dancers in this cube. Blastoise, Dragonair, Magnezone, and Hydreigon. This really needs to be reduced to something more manageable.
  • Po Town and similar effects are really important for non-stage 2 decks to keep pace.
  • We've probably leaned too hard into basics that set up rather than beat down. I'm not sure how to approach fixing this.
  • There are too many consistency cards in the cube right now relative to the number of players and the size of the pools they end up with.
  • Shuckle is not a reasonable card if there are going to be rain dancers in the cube. Needs to get cut immediately.

Goals for Revisions

Here's the short list of things that I want to keep at the forefront of my mind for the first round of revisions:
  • Straight up cut at least 10 cards with the goal of getting down to around 200 over a few revisions.
  • Replace some of the set up basics with attacking basics
  • Try to figure out what archetypical pokemon strategies are not accounted for in the cube. Is control/stall a thing? What does that look like?
  • Should we be favoring supporters over items to slow games down? Does that make play/draw less balanced? Or is getting the first evolution worth missing out on both the first supporter and first attack?

Cuts and Maybeboard

Here are some of the things that I'm thinking about cutting. Some to be replaced, others potentially not replaced.
  1. Exeggcute - this plays super well with all the cards that require discards, but feels kind of redundant to Training Court. Are two of this kind of effect necessary in such a small cube?
  2. Alolan Sandslashes feel kind of underpowered
  3. Lapras feels slow for what it does.
  4. Kyogre - redundant to other energy acceleration?
  5. Plusle - just worse than Minun? Probably better as an attacker of some kind.
  6. Mimikyu - it does set up and spread, but is kind of bad at both of those jobs.
  7. Mew - Maybe this gets better if we lean into stronger attacking basics? Right now it hasn't felt exciting.
  8. Cubone - We definitely underestimated the cost of taking two turns to get this attack off, even for one energy.
  9. Shuckle - this thing is disgusting and cannot exist alongside rain dancers. That kind of engine is way over what we're looking for.
  10. Gliscor - Generally feels like a weak evolution line, but is a way to status stall? I'm not sure what would replace it.
  11. Raichu - Feels weak? It's a lot of work to stall this way.
  12. Scramble Switch - We've got Float Stone and Fluffy Berry and Switch trainers. I can't imagine wanting this over other ACE Specs.
  13. Life Dew - Maybe I just haven't had the chance to draft a deck around this yet?
And here's the list of cards that I may want to try in future updates:
  1. Audino - Do the wave on a basic may be a good way to beat down, especially if we add more of Upper Energy and Twin Energy.
  2. Lucario - I kind of like Do the Wave as a Stage 1 attacking deck. There's some counter play from cards like Parallel City and it requires some commitment in terms of picking DCEs and ways to fill the bench highly.
  3. Raticate - is this a thing? I think I overvalue these effects because of my experience with MTG.
  4. Cursed Stone - Po Town and Crobats are huge for giving basic or stage 1 decks more reach against stage 2 decks. Maybe this is another card in that vein?
  5. Shedinja - Is this just a better Life Dew? It's easier to find and there's no way to shut off abilities right now.
  6. Shedinja - Maybe this pairs with Life Dew to make a deck that recycles those two cards? What's the stall end game though?
  7. Mr. Mime - The classic? Again, I'm just not sure what the end game is for a stall deck. I worry about making the plan too compact in terms of required picks as well.
  8. Cofagrigus - This is a way to recycle pokemon like Uxie that do things when you bench them, I guess?
  9. Articuno - I like the idea of this, but I'm fairly confident it's just not good.
  10. Cramorant - Splits the difference between spread and a reasonable basic attacker?
  11. Hawlucha - Okay setup pokemon, but also kind of attacks? Maybe.
  12. Zapdos - Hits super hard but makes you work for it? 
  13. Celebi - Reasonable attacker against rain dancers but also a set up pokemon for decks with many evolutions? This only works if we continue using rainbow basics.


Wrap Up

And that's where we're at. It's been an interesting project and we've had a lot of fun playing the games so far. That said, I think there's still a lot of refinement to be done here before everything is relatively balanced and there's a good diversity of approaches. I absolutely can't wait to bring this to our first gathering of friends post-quarantine and try to get a bunch of drafts in.

Friday, January 29, 2021

Flickering Noodle Serpents for Fun and Profit

 I've been trying to make Blue-White control work in Commander for a very long time. I've played with Ephara plus tokens and/or Planeswalkers. I've shifted to Raff with Planeswalkers, using Proteus Staff to find Deepglow Skate - the only other creature - to emblem up immediately. I've seen lots of interesting takes on Brago over the years, but none of them really captured my imagination because I don't like beating down.

Enter Yorion. This noodle serpent is everything that I ever wanted Brago to be, and I'm kind of astonished at how little traction it seems to have gotten in the months since Ikoria has been printed. Maybe it's burnout from Yorion being so good in other formats? I don't really know. What I do know is that I've held off on taking a look at Yorion because I haven't been super excited about Magic in awhile, but here we are.

So what does Yorion do that makes it so exciting? Fundamentally, it does a lot of the same things that Brago does. The most straightforward thing is that you can rebuy 'enters the battlefield' effects of various baubles and creatures. The second thing is that you can untap key non-land permanents like mana rocks. Last, you can reset things like Sagas or Planeswalkers.

Here's the thing. Yorion is a very different beast from Brago for several reasons, all related to Yorion being an 'enters the battlefield' ability rather than triggering off of combat damage. Critically, Yorion pairs with instant-speed flicker effects to do a number of really interesting things. Let's break those down.

First, you can use Yorion on opponent's turns as well as yours. That means that you can get a bunch of Yorion triggers per turn cycle instead of just one or two. That means that you can draw extra cards off of your Prophetic Prisms and Wall of Omens. Not only that, it means you can use your mana rocks on your turn, untap them on your end step, and repeat on each players' turn. That's a ton of extra cards and mana that you can leverage to pull ahead, stay ahead, and close out the game rapidly.

Second, you can use Yorion in conjunction with instant-speed flickers to protect your permanents from opposing sweepers or spot removal. I generally have an aversion to leaning too heavily on mana rocks because they get caught up in sweepers. Pairing them with Yorion means that you've got a board presence that generates a bunch of free cards and mana while also giving you some built-in ability to protect yourself from getting completely blown out by cards like Vandalblast and Austere Command.

Finally, you can use Yorion in conjunction with creatures like Restoration Angel to guarantee that you get to flicker up to your entire board every single turn without investing additional resources. Once you're at that point, you just need to manage your hand so you have a bunch of protection and leverage your extra cards and mana to close the game out.

In my mind, this is sort of a perfect storm of things that makes Yorion really fun to think about but gives the noodle serpent a really high likelihood of being really overbearing at most tables. You're incentivized to play a bunch of mana rocks - some of the more degenerate cards in the format anyway - and you can get extra use out of those to get even further ahead. Once you're ahead, it's relatively hard to break up Yorion loops for any considerable period of time, and those Yorion loops will eventually just bury the table in resources.

Let's break down the key pieces.

Flicker Effects

We're looking for things that function at instant-speed. Depending on what power level you're shooting for, there's a number of ways to make repeatable loops with the likes of Eldrazi Displacer, Deadeye Navigator, or even Archaeomancer plus Ghostly Flicker.

You can use effects like Charming Prince or Astral Drift that flicker and return Yorion at the end of your turn - you're just going to want to do everything you can to use them before your opponents leave their second main phase so that Yorion returns on that end step. It's important to note here that if Yorion enters the battlefield on an end step, all the permanents you flicker will be gone until the end step of the following turn.

For me, I'd rather stay away from the repeatable flickers and focus on instants and sorceries in the hopes that it helps strike the right balance of powerful but not overbearing. That means I'm looking for things like Cloudshift, Ephemerate, Essence Flux, and Restoration Angel. The one mana ones are probably worth running in almost any build, the real break point is going to be where you draw the line on two- and three-mana flickers like Flicker of Fate, Teferi's Time Twist, Ghostly Flicker, and Displace.

Mana Rocks

The key here is that you're looking first and foremost for mana rocks that enter the battlefield untapped so that you net mana when you flicker them. The second thing you're looking for is ones that have extra enters the battlefield effects. The third thing you're looking for is rocks that generate colored mana so you can cast spells on opposing turns instead of just ending up with a ton of colorless mana you can't use.

Obviously the super busted rocks are great here. Mana Crypt and Sol Ring let you get super far ahead very quickly. The thing is, cards like Grim Monolith, Basalt Monolith, and Mana Vault are also super busted here because you can untap them for 'free.' I really like cheap rocks that make colored mana for this style of deck, so Azorius Signet, Arcane Signet, and Talisman of Progress seem great. I also like rocks that you can cash in later in the game like Mind Stone and Hedron Archive. Mana Geode and even Darksteel Relic seem just fine, since they generate colored mana and help bridge you into more expensive and more powerful rocks.

Then we get to some of the really interesting stuff. The card I'm singly most interested in for this deck is Coveted Jewel. It's absurd to flicker beacuse it draws cards and makes colored mana to cast those cards. Not only that, but Yorion helps stop your opponent from stealing it. Gilded Lotus is another fine card that's similar, though less powerful.

Something that I'm very excited about is the prospect of pairing cards like Mirrormade and Phyrexian Metamorph with this card to get even bigger. It's important to note that clones cannot copy things that enter the battlefield at the same time as they do, so beware blindly flickering your entire board.

There are non-mana rock effects that serve a similar purpose - the 'free' cards from Urza block like Cloud of Faeries, Treachery, and Peregrine Drake.

Cantrip Baubles

Prophetic Prism is emblematic of what I want to pair with Yorion. Cheap artifacts that help smooth your draw early and then pair with Yorion going late to keep your hand full of gas. There's lots of things that can fill this role depending on what the rest of your deck looks like. Arcum's Astrolabe and Wall of Omens are simple things that just draw cards. There are other options like Alchemist's Vial and Sleeper Dart that give you some additional utility. There's also things that give you a little more selection like Watcher for Tomorrow. You could even go super deep on something like Trinket Mage or Tribute Mage to help find additional baubles to cast turn after turn.

Bringing Together the Artifact Engine

Something that I'm really excited about is that there are a lot of really interesting ways to make the artifact engine go even harder. The biggest problem with leaning hard into artifacts is that when you draw extra cards on opposing turns, you're going to draw a bunch of sorcery speed effects that are going to clog up your hand.

Enter Shimmer Myr, Raff Capashen, and Vedalken Orrery. Now your baubles help you draw more rocks and baubles which you can immediately play and leverage to do even more stuff. All the while, Yorion gives you the ability to protect the board you're building. 




But that's not all. Let's add Mirrorworks to the mix. Now every time your artifacts blink back in, you can make copies of key pieces like Coveted Jewel. This is effectively a great way to ensure that you can leverage most of the extra mana you're generating to continuously build your board. Not only that, but if the tokens would ever become a liability, you can flicker them out of existence with Yorion.

ETB Answers

The next piece of the puzzle is a means of actually controlling the game. Obviously instants and counterspells are going to be important. Things like Swords to Plowshares and Path to Exile are still going to be great. Free and cheap counterspells are going to be exceptional as well, particularly ones that can fight against instant-speed responses to your blink effects.

That said, the way you really make sure that your opponents can't mount a reasonable offense is by using Yorion in conjunction with flexible or repeatable answers.

The kinds of things that I'm most interested in are the like of Spine of Ish Sah, Act of Authority, and Reality Acid. Oblivion Ring and Detention Sphere are interesting because you can do Faceless Butcher tricks with them, but I don't know how good that ends up being.

Another category of answer that I'm very interested in are auras like Spreading Seas, Darksteel Mutation, and Imprisoned in the Moon. These are interesting because Yorion can flicker them out and then back in onto a different permanent than they were enchanting before, meaning that you can shift targets as the game evolves.

The Manifest Engine

The last big piece, in my mind, is a really cool engine that one of my friends utilized in their Brago deck. Manifest cards are a great way to turn Brago and Yorion into huge bursts of mana and advantage. If you can manifest lands or expensive permanents and then flicker them out, you can end up really far ahead.

In particular, I'm interested in pairing Cloudform, Lightform, and Heliod's Pilgrim, since they not only flip a card back face up, but also net you another manifest each loop. Scroll of Fate is a great way to give you a little more control over what you end up flickering.

Furthermore, for when you hit instants and sorceries, you've got Primordial Mist to make sure that you can cast the spells that you exile with manifest cards.

Winning the Game

This is one of the big questions that control decks have to wrangle with in Commander. You've shut down your opponents and drawn a billion cards. How are you actually going to end the game? There's lots of ways to do it, and I honestly don't know what the thing that makes the most sense is. To me, the most obvious choices are things like Altar of the Brood and Triskelion, but I'm sure there's a very straightforward way to convert Yorion loops into a win off of Thassa's Oracle or something similar.


So there's my breakdown of why I think Yorion is super interesting, but likely to be super overbearing. It's a combination of rewarding degenerate cards, repetitive play patterns, and combinations that are exceedingly difficult to break up. I haven't figured out exactly how I want to build mine to balance the cool things that Yorion can do with the overbearing play patterns that it is capable of, but this is where I'll be figuring it out.

Sunday, November 29, 2020

Breaking Down U150: Banned List and Staples

 In the last post, I broke down the basics of the format. This time I want to start getting into the details and help people start thinking about how games play, how to build decks, and what kinds of things are legal. To that end, let's start with the cards that aren't legal and get that out of the way.

The banned list for the existing format is a little bit of a mystery. There's a list on the homepage for the format, but that list seems to disagree with random posts that I saw on the facebook page. So I don't know which set of things to trust. Consequently, I'm going to use the list that's an actual list and all in one place as a starting point and go from there. Here's the list of cards that are banned in the 'official' format. There are three lists - first the cards that are outright banned, follow by two lists of cards which cannot be played together.

Banned List
Restricted List A
Restricted List B
Some of these cards make a lot of sense to me. Others seem completely nonsensical. In general, it seems like cards fall into a couple of categories. Let's break the down.

Combotastic Synergies

I did not know that there were infinite combos in Pokemon, but I guess I shouldn't be shocked. These three Pokemon form the core of a common infinite that I suppose it makes sense to ban. The cards combo with any 'Rain Dance' style pokemon like Blastoise that lets you play multiple energies per turn.

It's fairly trivial to find Shuckle, with teams up with your Rain Dancer to draw a bunch of cards. There's a handful of ways to pick up your Shuckle and all the energies attached to it to do it all over again and draw a whole bunch of cards. The trick is to do this until you can find and play Espeon, which lets you pick up energies for free. Now you can play energies one at a time until you draw your deck. From there, you can do the same trick, but with Forretress to slowly knock out all of the opposing Pokemon.

No thanks, I'd rather not deal with this. I don't know that all the pieces need to be banned, but I'm having a hard time imagining much good coming from them being legal. I guess Shuckle is kind of interesting just as a draw engine, but is that worth it? Probably not.

Prison Effects



A number of the banned cards seem to boil down to Pokemon that easily lock opponents out of taking key game actions. I'm not sure that I've played enough games to know why these ones are banned while others aren't, but I'll take a stab.

Prison effects seem to be a key part of the Pokemon game. Some research shows that formats have been defined by some cards like Vileplume, Aerodactyl, Zebstrika, and Garbodor. A large number of decks that I've been people build for this format play Spiritomb. 

Generally speaking, it looks like the decision on which of these effects are too good boils down to a combination of whether or not the effect is one-sided, how easy it is to get into play, and how fragile it is. One-sided attacks, especially those that don't require much set up in terms of evolutions or energies, seem to be clearly over the line. Static powers with exceptions that you get to build around while your opponent cannot also seem to be too good.

Raw Efficiency


There's a couple of kinds of things going on here, but the gist of it is that these cards are very efficient. It seems to me that the question is when 'very efficient' becomes 'too efficient.'

Burning Roar off of Entei is an easy way to set up for a follow up Combat Blaze. In my limited experience, bench space is at a premium and I guess I can imagine that a two-energy attack that regularly hits for 80-120 with minimal setup is pretty unreasonable, especially since the attack also sets up your other pokemon and is attached to a high HP basic.

Trashalanche off of Garbodor is the same kind of thing. Sure, it's an evolution Pokemon, but believe me when I say that that attack can very consistently hit for 200+ damage with minimal setup.

Sableye rebuying items seems pretty good, but I don't know if I'm convinced that it's too good. My limited experience tells me that Pokemon is a game where resources are pretty free, but tempo is what's important. Investing an entire turn and an energy into rebuying cards feels like a very real cost to me. I'm definitely willing to believe that I'm wrong and this card is exceedingly unfun, especially in conjunction with something like Crushing Hammer or Hypnotoxic Laser.

Miltank is next, and I'll be honest - I truly do not understand why this card would be banned. One energy for potentially 80 damage is no joke, but it requires set up. Getting Stage 2 pokemon into play seems like a real cost to me, especially when there are so many forced switches running around to snipe key players off of your bench. There are so many unfair things that you can be doing in this game that I don't see why this is particularly egregious.

Last, we've got Greninja BREAK. If you can get this into play eary, targeted 60 damage per turn is a huge deal. Sniping off utility pokemon without needing to be the active pokemon, much less attack, feels a little beyond the pale.

Oops, I Win


One more card that's in its own category because it's something that I didn't think about. Seeker seems kind of innocuous on its face and might genuinely be okay given the new rules update on supporters. The problem with this card was that it could frrequently lead to wins on the first turn of the game. If your opponent only leads with one pokemon and you can find a way to kill it outside of combat, you just win the game. That might seem like a difficult thing to do, but lots of basic pokemon only have ~60 HP, and there are lots of cards like Galarian Zigzagoon and its evolutions that just stack up damage. Combine those with some Scoop Up effects and a Seeker to bounce your opponent's backup pokemon and it's not nearly as difficult to imagine a fairly consistent means of ending games before they really start.

Restricted List Interactions   

The cards on the restricted list seem to be trying to break up a pretty straightforward combination to me. Pokemon that can shuffle damage around and pokemon that can heal it off. Alakazam and Reuniclus can put damage wherever it's convenient to have. You can stack up damage on cards like Jumpluff or Lopunny and just bounce them back to your hand.

I doln't know why the cards that rebuy pokemon tools are on this list too. Maybe it's because of denying opponent's prizes with Life Dew? I can't find anything exactly like the Lopunny interactions, but I'm sure there's some kind of reason.

Approach to Deckbuilding

First thing's first - you do not want to be playing fair in this game. You should be looking to find something that feels degenerate. That could be cheating extra energies into play, ramping out Stage 2 Pokemon, or setting up huge attacks with Basic or Stage 1 Pokemon early in the game. There are lots of ways to lock your opponent out of different kinds of trainers or spread damage among fragile bench pokemon. There's 20-some years of cards and lots of cool space to explore - just don't fool yourself into thinking that this plays like Magic.

The biggest difference is that there aren't color requirements to play most of the cards. Trainers, Items, and Supporters are going to make up something like 50% or more of most decks, and they have no 'color identity' associated with them. The effects of these cards range from allowing you to draw a bunch of extra cards to searching your deck for specific pokemon. There are pokemon that have these kinds of effects too, and a lot of them don't require you to actually invest any energies to use them.

What does this all mean? A couple things. First and foremost, your goal should be to make sure that you can look at a lot of cards, very quickly. That's key to making sure that you can consistently execute your gameplan quickly. Second, you should be prepared for a lot of decks to start with a lot of similar support cards.

Because there are so many powerful trainers that fit into decks regardless of archetype or 'color,' there's a fairly long list of things that you should consider including in just about every deck. What follows is my trying to categorize and list some of the cards that seem like they should at least be considered for the majority of decks with the idea that it will give people someplace to start.

Sunday, November 15, 2020

Pokemon Singleton - Reverse Engineering Unlimited 150

About two months ago, I started asking if some friends would be interested in trying to make a Commander-ish format out of the Pokemon TCG. After a little bit of back and forth, I started doing some research and discovered that people had previously started doing work on exactly the kind of thing I was looking for.

Realistically, Unlimited 150 is a 100 card, singleton format that has a lot more in common with something like Canadian Highlander than Commander, but it's definitely a good place to start. Currently, I'm planning on writing a series of three posts about this:

  1. Introduction to the Format
  2. Staples, the banned list, and my watch list
  3. Basic deck construction and some decklists

The first thing I want to clarify is that, for reasons that we're about to get into, I very much do not want to play actual U150, but rather use it as a point for jumping off and discover if there's a fun game to add to the rotation of things that I regularly play with friends.

In digging around, I was able to find a number of interesting resources for the Unlimited 150. I'm going to do my best to break down what I've learned and what my takeaways are, but I encourage anyone interested to go do their own digging.

Official Pokemon Rules

If you're completely unfamiliar with the Pokemon TCG (or haven't played since the GBC game, like me), I'd recommend starting with this Tolarian Community College video to get the gist of the rules.

In general, the goal is to win by either knocking out all of your opponent's pokemon, taking all six of your prizes, or decking. You'll do that in a fashion which is very similar to magic. You've got a main phase where you can play Pokemon, items, and up to one supporter card. Much like your land drop in Magic, you can attach one energy card per turn. Finally, you can make one attack that immediately ends your turn.

Some caveats that aren't necessarily immediately obvious:
  • Mulligans are only a thing if you don't have a basic pokemon in your opening hand. If this is the case, you have to reveal your hand to your opponent and shuffle up again. You repeat this process until you find a hand with a basic pokemon, but you do not go down to fewer starting cards in hand.
  • Pokemon can't evolve on a player's first turn or the first turn that pokemon comes into play. For example, you cannot play a Wartortle from your hand to evolve a Squirtle on turn one. Similarly, once you do play your Wartortle, you'll have to wait until the following turn to play your Blastoise. There are cards that break these rules, but we'll get to those at a later point.
  • The player going first does get to draw a card on their first turn. However, they do not get to make an attack or play a supporter on their first turn.

U150 Rules

One of the objections I have with U150 is that it has a very involved set of rules that are very hard to decipher if you are not deeply entrenched in the game. Still, in order to give people the same kind of starting point, I'm going to break down their rule set as briefly as I can here.

On Deck Construction

Decks are 100 cards and singleton besides basic energies. Your deck can only include four copies of any card with the same name. This is important because, unlike in Magic, names of pokemon cards are not necessarily unique. If you do a search for Eevee, for example, there are many different Eevees that do different things. You can play up to four unique copies of cards named eevee to give you deck something resembling consistency.

There's also a banned list and two restricted lists for this format, but we'll get into those later.

On Prizes and Mulligans

100 card singleton means that decks are much more inconsistent than they usually are. Additionally, crucial cards being 'prized' (randomly chosen as one of your six prize cards) means that you may not have access to key cards. Their solution is that players draw a fifteen card hand and select which eight of those fiteen cards will be their prizes for the game. This means that U150 uses eight prizes instead of six and that you get a huge amount of selection about what is in your hand and you won't be surprised as to what tools are unavailable to you in the early game.

In addition, each player gets one free mulligan if they don't like their initial fifteen card hand.

On the Legality of Pokemon

Like many other games, Pokemon has an enormous amount of power creep. Just compare the relative sizes of these pokemon to get an idea of how radically the game has changed over the years. Looking at the HP should give you some idea, but also the EX and TAG TEAM pokemon are basics! 
The short story is that older pokemon cards have absolutely no way of keeping up with how newer cards have scaled. The HP and damage on newer cards is just so much higher that they outclass huge portions of the cards that have been printed. The way that this is balanced is that these EX and GX pokemon are typically worth more than one prize when you knock them out, but the raw stats on them are just incredibly overwhelming.

Here's where the name of the format comes in. In Unlimited 150, basic pokemon with more than 150 HP are banned. That means that Blastoise EX and Blastoise & Piplup GX would not be legal in U150. There will absolutely still be older cards that are very much outclassed by newer ones, but this does a good job in making sure that you can reasonably play decks that are not built around monstrously efficient Pokemon EX, GX, or TAG TEAMs.

Friday, June 12, 2020

Free Gifts Ungiven

Today I want to talk about my favorite card of all time: Gifts Ungiven. Gifts is a card that has been used for a lot of interesting things in an enormous number of formats, from Kamigawa Block Constructed all the way through Vintage. It's also a card that's currently banned in Commander.

The crux of this is that my very biased opinion is that Gifts should be legal in Commander. That it is no more degenerate than a myriad of other cards that are already legal and that its existence on the banned list is uniquely perplexing.

I want to start by looking at the kinds of things that Gifts does in the formats it's been legal in to give some context for the kinds of games that it can contribute to. Those things can range from super interactive to incredibly linear and everything in between. If that's not your thing, you can feel free to skip to the next break.

_________________________________________________________________________________

Gifts in Block Constructed

In Block, Gifts was a dominating strategy. The idea was that you could play a grindy control deck that used Gifts as a late game engine. Sensei's Divining Top teamed up with Gifts, Sakura-Tribe Elder and Kodama's Reach to give you an enormous amount of selection. Your gifts piles frequently included Hana Kami, Soulless Revival, and Eerie Procession (which served as a second copy of Soulless Revival). The idea was that you could then start splicing Soulless Revival onto your various Arcane spells to rebuy Hana Kami over and over again. You'd slowly lock the game out by looping spells like Hideous Laughter, Cranial Extraction, and Ethereal Haze.

Spliced Gifts by Frank Karsten

Gifts in Standard

Ever since watching Frank Karsten crush Worlds in 2005 with it, Greater Gifts has been one of my favorite decks of all time. This deck shares a lot of ideas with the Block Constructed version of the deck. There's still Sakura-Tribe Elder, Farseek, and Kodama's Reach as fixing and acceleration. There's still exactly two unique removal spells. Now there are two unique recursion spells to make Gifts piles easier in Reclaim and Recollect. The key difference between this deck and the Block one is the end game. This time the end game involves sacrificing Kokusho and Yosei to Greater Good over and over again courtesy of Goryo's Vengeance. It's worth noting that this is the deck that first popularized the gameplay pattern of using Gifts as a double Entomb to guarantee that your Kagemaro, Kokusho, or Yosei ended up in the graveyard.

Gifts in Extended

Extended is where some of my favorite Gifts decks of all time have existed. This is the format where the cardpool starts to get deep enough that you can play tons of singletons to get into some really interesting Gifts piles. This is where you'd first see Gifts paired with Life from the Loam and Academy Ruins to loop artifacts like Engineered Explosives or Mindslaver if you were given enough time. It's also where you'd see Gifts paired with Glittering Wish and Living Wish for even more flexibility. This is also where we start seeing cards that want to end up in the graveyard as part of Gifts piles, such as Cabal Therapy and Genesis. 



Gifts in Modern

This is, admittedly, where things start to go a little off the rails. Gifts in Modern is primarily relegated to two things. You are either setting up a storm kill with Past in Flames or setting up an Unburial Rites. The format is too fast and too diverse for anything else to really be worthwhile. That said, that hasn't stopped people from exploring Rock-style decks with Gifts Ungiven featuring the likes of Lingering Souls, Life from the Loam, and retrace spells.

For how linear Gifts frequently is in Modern, this deck shows off the kinds of things I wish were possible. Gifts packages involving Life from the Loam left you start looping utility lands like Ghost Quarter, Gavony Township, and Treetop Village. You can set up Urborg, Tomb of Yawgmoth and Raven's Crime in attrition-heavy matchups. You can do all kinds of crazy Sun Titan tricks in conjunction with Liliana of the Veil and Knight of the Reliquary. Sure, there are some fairly linear choices, but there's also an infinitely complex and interesting puzzle of non-standard piles that include mixes of removal spells, lands, and other key pieces.

Gifts Legacy and Vintage

Here's the thing: Gifts Ungiven doesn't really see play in Legacy and Vintage. There was a time when Gifts was restricted in Vintage, but both formats have really passed it by. Intuition still sees occasional play in Legacy as a way to set up Accumulated Knowledge, Life from the Loam, or Sevinne's Reclamation, but that's about the end of it. To my knowledge, the original Gifts deck in Vintage was Meandeck Gifts - a deck fundamentally built around the pile of Yawgmoth's Will, Tinker, Recoup, and Time Walk. That said, in Vintage you have enough busted singletons that there are all manner of interesting piles involving Ancestral Recall and Yawgmoth's Will or just piles of mana. That flexibility led to a lot of interesting choices until Paradoxical Outcome came around and did all of those things better.

_____________________________________________________________________

Gifts In Commander

So what does this mean for Commander? Gifts is a card with a really interesting legacy that only sees niche play these days. It's banned in Commander for many of the reasons that it's played in Modern. It has the potential to be an instant-speed way to set up a super linear way of either ending the game on the spot or locking your opponent out of the game. 

Gifts Ungiven is unlike any other card on the banned list. It doesn't fit the old 'egregiously expensive' criteria for things like Power. It isn't a permanent that centralizes the rest of the game on itself like Primeval Titan, Sylvan Primordial, or Griselbrand. It's not a busted mana engine like Tolarian Academy. It doesn't immediately bury the table in cards like Yawgmoth's Bargain. It doesn't cheat anything into play like Tinker. It doesn't reset the game. Gifts is a tutor that is only ever as good as the supporting cast. Let's be clear, there are absolutely dozens of Gifts piles across ever possible color combination that will end games. 

Some people choose to push Commander to the limits with cEDH. At higher-power tables, an end step Gifts will probably lead to someone untapping and winning the game. That said, there are plenty of cEDH decks that can easily be ported down for budget decks and lower-power builds. Despite that, I never see Godo or Najeela combo off. I rarely see games won off of Laboratory Maniac. I've never seen a Gitrog Monster deck combo off with state-based effects. If someone wants to do something busted in your games, they already have all the tools they need to do so - the legality of Gifts Ungiven isn't going to fundamentally change that.

If we're going to judge Gifts based on its worst-case scenario, then what about other tutors? Why are they exempt from that criteria? Are we really going to argue that Gifts Ungiven is more efficient or has more unfair applications than the likes of vintage staples like Vampiric Tutor and Demonic Tutor? I have never seen a Tainted Pact or Demonic Consultation cast in the absence of Thassa's Oracle or Laboratory Maniac. Despite that, we still see people casting tutors for lands, silver bullets, and answers in lower-powered games. Fundamentally, people can and do play fair with busted tutors. We've collectively agreed not to judge them based on their most unfair applications, but to let different people play with them in different ways.

People who want to break Gifts are going to break it, there's absolutely no question about that. That said, just slotting Gifts into an existing deck is unlikely to break it. Some people will just get some combination of four haymakers and answers. Still others will do something in between that sets up some kind of value engine. This dichotomy of fair and unfair applications isn't unique to Gifts Ungiven. What is unique is that Gifts Ungiven is banned while every other tutor that has ever been printed (sans Tinker and Primeval Titan) is legal.
TLDR

All I'm trying to say is that it seems odd to me that Gifts Ungiven is the single tutor in the entirety of Magic that crosses the line on power, efficiency, or gameplay concerns. If we can be trusted to play with degenerate engines like Hermit Druid and super efficient tutors like Demonic Tutor without breaking Rule 0, I think we can be trusted to have Gifts Ungiven.