Sunday, November 29, 2020

Breaking Down U150: Banned List and Staples

 In the last post, I broke down the basics of the format. This time I want to start getting into the details and help people start thinking about how games play, how to build decks, and what kinds of things are legal. To that end, let's start with the cards that aren't legal and get that out of the way.

The banned list for the existing format is a little bit of a mystery. There's a list on the homepage for the format, but that list seems to disagree with random posts that I saw on the facebook page. So I don't know which set of things to trust. Consequently, I'm going to use the list that's an actual list and all in one place as a starting point and go from there. Here's the list of cards that are banned in the 'official' format. There are three lists - first the cards that are outright banned, follow by two lists of cards which cannot be played together.

Banned List
Restricted List A
Restricted List B
Some of these cards make a lot of sense to me. Others seem completely nonsensical. In general, it seems like cards fall into a couple of categories. Let's break the down.

Combotastic Synergies

I did not know that there were infinite combos in Pokemon, but I guess I shouldn't be shocked. These three Pokemon form the core of a common infinite that I suppose it makes sense to ban. The cards combo with any 'Rain Dance' style pokemon like Blastoise that lets you play multiple energies per turn.

It's fairly trivial to find Shuckle, with teams up with your Rain Dancer to draw a bunch of cards. There's a handful of ways to pick up your Shuckle and all the energies attached to it to do it all over again and draw a whole bunch of cards. The trick is to do this until you can find and play Espeon, which lets you pick up energies for free. Now you can play energies one at a time until you draw your deck. From there, you can do the same trick, but with Forretress to slowly knock out all of the opposing Pokemon.

No thanks, I'd rather not deal with this. I don't know that all the pieces need to be banned, but I'm having a hard time imagining much good coming from them being legal. I guess Shuckle is kind of interesting just as a draw engine, but is that worth it? Probably not.

Prison Effects



A number of the banned cards seem to boil down to Pokemon that easily lock opponents out of taking key game actions. I'm not sure that I've played enough games to know why these ones are banned while others aren't, but I'll take a stab.

Prison effects seem to be a key part of the Pokemon game. Some research shows that formats have been defined by some cards like Vileplume, Aerodactyl, Zebstrika, and Garbodor. A large number of decks that I've been people build for this format play Spiritomb. 

Generally speaking, it looks like the decision on which of these effects are too good boils down to a combination of whether or not the effect is one-sided, how easy it is to get into play, and how fragile it is. One-sided attacks, especially those that don't require much set up in terms of evolutions or energies, seem to be clearly over the line. Static powers with exceptions that you get to build around while your opponent cannot also seem to be too good.

Raw Efficiency


There's a couple of kinds of things going on here, but the gist of it is that these cards are very efficient. It seems to me that the question is when 'very efficient' becomes 'too efficient.'

Burning Roar off of Entei is an easy way to set up for a follow up Combat Blaze. In my limited experience, bench space is at a premium and I guess I can imagine that a two-energy attack that regularly hits for 80-120 with minimal setup is pretty unreasonable, especially since the attack also sets up your other pokemon and is attached to a high HP basic.

Trashalanche off of Garbodor is the same kind of thing. Sure, it's an evolution Pokemon, but believe me when I say that that attack can very consistently hit for 200+ damage with minimal setup.

Sableye rebuying items seems pretty good, but I don't know if I'm convinced that it's too good. My limited experience tells me that Pokemon is a game where resources are pretty free, but tempo is what's important. Investing an entire turn and an energy into rebuying cards feels like a very real cost to me. I'm definitely willing to believe that I'm wrong and this card is exceedingly unfun, especially in conjunction with something like Crushing Hammer or Hypnotoxic Laser.

Miltank is next, and I'll be honest - I truly do not understand why this card would be banned. One energy for potentially 80 damage is no joke, but it requires set up. Getting Stage 2 pokemon into play seems like a real cost to me, especially when there are so many forced switches running around to snipe key players off of your bench. There are so many unfair things that you can be doing in this game that I don't see why this is particularly egregious.

Last, we've got Greninja BREAK. If you can get this into play eary, targeted 60 damage per turn is a huge deal. Sniping off utility pokemon without needing to be the active pokemon, much less attack, feels a little beyond the pale.

Oops, I Win


One more card that's in its own category because it's something that I didn't think about. Seeker seems kind of innocuous on its face and might genuinely be okay given the new rules update on supporters. The problem with this card was that it could frrequently lead to wins on the first turn of the game. If your opponent only leads with one pokemon and you can find a way to kill it outside of combat, you just win the game. That might seem like a difficult thing to do, but lots of basic pokemon only have ~60 HP, and there are lots of cards like Galarian Zigzagoon and its evolutions that just stack up damage. Combine those with some Scoop Up effects and a Seeker to bounce your opponent's backup pokemon and it's not nearly as difficult to imagine a fairly consistent means of ending games before they really start.

Restricted List Interactions   

The cards on the restricted list seem to be trying to break up a pretty straightforward combination to me. Pokemon that can shuffle damage around and pokemon that can heal it off. Alakazam and Reuniclus can put damage wherever it's convenient to have. You can stack up damage on cards like Jumpluff or Lopunny and just bounce them back to your hand.

I doln't know why the cards that rebuy pokemon tools are on this list too. Maybe it's because of denying opponent's prizes with Life Dew? I can't find anything exactly like the Lopunny interactions, but I'm sure there's some kind of reason.

Approach to Deckbuilding

First thing's first - you do not want to be playing fair in this game. You should be looking to find something that feels degenerate. That could be cheating extra energies into play, ramping out Stage 2 Pokemon, or setting up huge attacks with Basic or Stage 1 Pokemon early in the game. There are lots of ways to lock your opponent out of different kinds of trainers or spread damage among fragile bench pokemon. There's 20-some years of cards and lots of cool space to explore - just don't fool yourself into thinking that this plays like Magic.

The biggest difference is that there aren't color requirements to play most of the cards. Trainers, Items, and Supporters are going to make up something like 50% or more of most decks, and they have no 'color identity' associated with them. The effects of these cards range from allowing you to draw a bunch of extra cards to searching your deck for specific pokemon. There are pokemon that have these kinds of effects too, and a lot of them don't require you to actually invest any energies to use them.

What does this all mean? A couple things. First and foremost, your goal should be to make sure that you can look at a lot of cards, very quickly. That's key to making sure that you can consistently execute your gameplan quickly. Second, you should be prepared for a lot of decks to start with a lot of similar support cards.

Because there are so many powerful trainers that fit into decks regardless of archetype or 'color,' there's a fairly long list of things that you should consider including in just about every deck. What follows is my trying to categorize and list some of the cards that seem like they should at least be considered for the majority of decks with the idea that it will give people someplace to start.

Burst Card Drawing

This is the thing that you have to get the most used to playing this game over Magic. This is much more of a game about tempo and leveraging very specific interactions than it is about managing quantity of resources - at least most of the time. That's in large part because of cards like these ones that let you generate huge bursts of card advantage in one fell swoop. Why would you want to go around trying to one-for-one your opponent into the ground when they could just draw a wheel of fortune and chain two or three of them together on the following turn?

Pokemon
Items
Supporters

In my brief experience, there's sort of two kinds of decks. There's some that want to lean hard into Professor Oak effects and all the similar supporters because they just want to power through their deck looking for specific combinations of redundant effects. There are others that are heavily reliant on singleton copies of particular effects and are desperately afraid of effects that require you to discard your hand. These decks are more likely to max out on Cynthia and Professor Oak's New Theory before touching the actual Wheel of Fortunes. That said, lots of decks are going to run just about every single one of these.


These cards are all super good. That said, be wary of the raw number of supporters that you put in your deck. You can only play one per turn and not on the first turn if you're on the play. You don't want your hands jammed up with supporters that don't do anything too frequently, even if their effects are super powerful.


Sustained Card Drawing

Another big difference between Pokemon and other games that I've played is not just that there's absurd burst card drawing, but that you can do it over and over again. There are a myriad of Pokemon and a handful of other effects that are happy to let you draw multiple extra cards every turn they stay in play. 

Here, I've documented just a couple of that kind of effect, focusing on effects that just need to be in play, rather than in the active spot or requirng an attack. Be aware, though, that there are a TON of pokemon that are happy to draw you multiple cards or tutor for multiple cards if you're willing to invest energy and an attack step.

Pokemon
Most of these are pretty straightforward, but I wanted to mention one in particular as a really interesting corner case: Porygon 2. I just mentioned that a huge downside of supporters is that you can only play one per turn and so they have a tendency to rot in your hand if you hit multiples. This card fixes that problem. Additionally, it gives you a way to play supporters when you're stuck underneath something like Vileplume. The point is that it may not read like a draw engine, but it's a super powerful and flexible card that can certainly fill that role, among others.


Tutors

Generally speaking, the subgame with tutors in Pokemon is a question of specificity and tempo. There's lots of cards that search for pokemon with minimal costs, especially pokemon with different kinds of restrictions. You want to tutor for a busted trainer card? Now you're going to have to do some work.

Pokemon
It may look like there's a minimal cost to some of these, but let me assure you that putting Lapras and Jirachi EX into your deck is not free. Every now and then you're going to open with a hand that has just Lapras for a basic and a fistful of energies and supporters that don't help you do better. Fast tutors attached to pokemon are very, very good, but they are far from free.

It's also worth noting that there's a huge difference between tutoring Pokemon into play vs into your hand. There are lots of Pokemon like Lapras and Inteleon that do things when you play them from your hand but not when you cheat them into play.

It's also worth noting here just how consistent you can make your early turns if you really commit to it. There are a lot of ways to tutor for whatever basic pokemon you want to lead with, even without using supporters for extra looks when you're on the play. Is that a good thing? I have no idea, but I've been actually astonished at how frequently I can put Spiritomb into my active spot to lock people out of trainers before they've taken their first turn.


Disruption

Disruption in this game is weird. There's a couple obvious axes to fight on. Specifically energy, evolutions, and making favorable exchanges. If you can set up knockouts on key pokemon that your opponent has invested a bunch of resources in, that's obviously great. However, you can also fight over quantity of resources, at least somewhat, or whether or not those resources even do anything. We've seen a handful of cards that are banned that lock people out of trainers, items, abilities or other such things.

Pokemon

Supporters
There's a couple of cards that I want to call out in particular here. Effects like Judge and Marnie are kind of hit or miss. Sometimes you play out your hand and get to draw four cards while putting your opponent from seven down to four. Other times you're both on low resources and it's just as likely to find them a way to break the stalemate. N and Rocket's Admin are basically the same card, but are a great catch-up mechanism, especially as you get further and further behind.

Gust of Wind and other effects like it are a great way to snag knock outs on key utility pokemon, like the Porygon 2's of the format. It's especially good when it can drag double-prize pokemon like Shaymin EX into the active to put you super far ahead in terms of prizes.

Last, I want to specifically mention Goop Gas Attack and Hex Maniac. We've been playing Goop Gas Attack as if it were just another Hex Maniac - I don't know how the official rules distinguish Pokemon Powers from Poke-bodies from abilities, but they all kind of feel the same to me. There are lots of decks built around the effects of particular Pokemon. Whether you're trying to use Rain Dance to set up attackers or Porygon 2 to draw some extra cards, these cards can lock you out of those kinds of effect. Not only that, but you can use various recursion effects to do this turn after turn while you try to cobble together a knock out on the problematic pokemon.

Recursion

When we start talking about recursion, you're going to have to set your expectations differently than you do for Magic. There are way fewer cards that just rebuy whatever card you're looking for. More often, you're looking at shuffling cards back into your deck and trying to draw back into them. Let's take a look:

Items
Supporters
Cards that are absolutely busted but may not immediately read that way: Item Finder, Junk Arm, and Dowsing Machine. I cannot overstate how many cards you are going to have seen by the third or fourth turn of the game. The ability to basically tutor out of your graveyard is absolutely enormous, especially given how many busted Trainers there are in this game.

Besides that, there's a lot of very medium effects. Rescue Stretcher and Pokemon Retriever are sort of the premier Pokemon recursion effects. They're great if you're just trying to rebuy one powerful basic. Not as good if you're trying to set your Stage 2 up all over again.

It's definitely worth mentioning that Lysandre's Trump Card in particular is much better than it reads. The ability to draw a billion cards over two or three turns trying to set up your board and break your opponent's up and then recycle all those cards and do it all over again is not something that you should underestimate.


Utility Stuff

This last group here is a mishmash of stuff that didn't really fit anywhere, but are critical effects that you're going to want to be mindful of when you're figuring out how to build your deck.

Bench Management
Acceleration
Tools
I want to talk about the bench management stuff in particular for a moment. You've only got five bench slots unless you're going to invest in Sky Field. It sounds like a lot, but it really isn't and you're going to need ways to make space. Various Scoop Up effects do a great job of letting you either make space or rebuy powerful effects like Uxie or Shaymin EX. Quick rules aside: for something like a Blastoise, Scoop Up Net or AZ will pick up all of them pokemon cards (evolutions don't count as 'attachments').

In terms of acceelerating, you just want to be mindful that everyone is going to be trying to do something fast and be aware of what tools you have to be faster. Single energy cards that can generate multiple energy are very good for this. So are Supporter or pokemon engines that let you attach extra energies, either out of your hand or from the discard. 


Points and Watch List

The last thing I want to touch on really quickly is a watchlist of things that I'm tentatively concerned about and talk about why they might be problematic for the format so that people can keep an eye on it and share any positive or negative experiences they have with the cards.

It's fair to assume that anything that was on the previous banned list is on the watchlist and if things feel especially overbearing or unfun they'll end up being banned, at least from our games. That said, there's a couple of other general categories of effects that I'd like to keep an eye on.

Broken Time-Space and Forest of Giant Plants

I love Broken Time-Space, but it's name includes 'Broken' for a reason. This card does a great job of letting Stage 2 evolution decks keep up with the super powerful Stage 1 EX and GX pokemon that exist in modern Pokemon. That said, it's also disgustingly powerful in conjunction with pokemon that do things when they evolve. Things that stand out in particular are Alolan Ninetales GX and the Drizzile/Inteleon chain that tutor for items.

With Drizzile in particular, each time you go all the way up the evolution chain, you net three items, one of which can be some kind of Scoop Up Net, Scoop Up Cyclone, or Devolution Spray. Those cards let you go up the chain again, finding more Scoop Ups or Item Finders. At some point, you can assemble a huge board of evolution pokemon by exhausting your various Pokeballs and Pokemon Communications, Professor Oak your way into a new hand, and then still have enough tutors left over to grab an Energy Removal, Goop Gas Attack, and Lass to completely demolish an opponent's ability to reasonably rebuild.

I consistently take ~5 minute turns with this card in play. It's not like Magic where there's a bunch of interaction either, it's just five minutes of me rifling through my deck figuring out what order I want to tutor for about two dozen cards to maximize the number of cards I get to see in between.

I don't know if Forest of Giant Plants is reasonable. Or if Broken Time-Space is okay without the evolutions that search for items. Once more people are playing games and have experienced what playing with Broken-Time Space is like, I think it'll be easier to make that kind of assessment, but I would not be surprised to see that it's the kind of card that keeps getting broken.

GX Pokemon

This is a super broad category, and I'm doing it that way intentionally. The numbers on GX pokemon are absolutely enormous relative to normal basic and evolution pokemon. I'm not sure that it's a problem right now, but I can certainly imagine a world in which Broken Time-Space gets banned and then Stage 2 decks can't keep up with Stage 1 GX decks, especially given how good cards like Sylveon GX and Espeon GX are, particularly in conjunction with Eevees that cheat on evolution timing while also generating card advantage.

Do I know that these are going to be problematic? Absolutely not. It's completely possible that every deck includes a handful of on-theme GX Pokemon and that the downside of them being worth double prizes balances them relative to everything else in the format. It seems about equally likely to me that the raw size of them puts a huge limitation on the kinds of 'normal' Pokemon that you can play, since you have to reasonably be able to knock out a GX Pokemon in one or two hits. Which way will things play out? Playing games is the only way we're going to figure it out.

Generic Tutors

The last thing on my list for the time being is yet another very broad category, but I think it asks two very fundamental questions. How much consistency do we want decks to have and how similar do we want decks to be? Coming from Magic, I'm actually astonished at how similarly games tend to play out due to just how many cards you can look at turn by turn, and I don't know how reasonable that is. That said, it could absolutely be because I'm only getting small look at the format due to the particular decks that I can currently play against.

So what kinds of things would I be looking to restrict if consistency and homogeneity are serious issues? The tutors that are too open-ended for too little cost. Luxury Ball and base set Computer Search are probably the flagbearers for this, but Lapras and Uxie are also cards that give decks an incredible amount of consistency for fairly limited cost. Those effects would still exist in the forms of Jirachi EX and Shaymin EX, but those cards at least have the downside of being worth two prizes if your opponent can force them into the active spot.

Where do you draw the line? I have absolutely no idea. It depends whether this feels like an issue at all. If it does, then how serious is it? 

Points

One last thought is that some of these issues could reasonably be resolved by imposing a Canadian Highlander-style restricted list that uses point values to limit how many of the busted cards you can play with. For anyone who is unfamiliar, the idea is that all the most busted cards are assigned a point value based on how unfair they are and there is an upper limit on the number of points that can be included in a deck.

Part of the fun of these eternal formats is getting to do unfair things. A point system allows people to do the busted things, but forces them to balance consistency and power, hopefully leading to more variety overall.

This is simultaneously much bigger and less all-encompassing than I thought it would be when I first started, but I sincerely hope it was helpful, at least as a starting point. If anyone has more questions after looking this over, I'd be happy to discuss further!



1 comment:

  1. The bouncing tool Pokémon are complex banned because you can remove damage by using Pokémon like Unown G from Great Encounters. Move damage to it, attach it, bounce it, repeat. Not sure I agree that's too good to be allowed, but that's why.

    ReplyDelete