Friday, June 12, 2020

Free Gifts Ungiven

Today I want to talk about my favorite card of all time: Gifts Ungiven. Gifts is a card that has been used for a lot of interesting things in an enormous number of formats, from Kamigawa Block Constructed all the way through Vintage. It's also a card that's currently banned in Commander.

The crux of this is that my very biased opinion is that Gifts should be legal in Commander. That it is no more degenerate than a myriad of other cards that are already legal and that its existence on the banned list is uniquely perplexing.

I want to start by looking at the kinds of things that Gifts does in the formats it's been legal in to give some context for the kinds of games that it can contribute to. Those things can range from super interactive to incredibly linear and everything in between. If that's not your thing, you can feel free to skip to the next break.

_________________________________________________________________________________

Gifts in Block Constructed

In Block, Gifts was a dominating strategy. The idea was that you could play a grindy control deck that used Gifts as a late game engine. Sensei's Divining Top teamed up with Gifts, Sakura-Tribe Elder and Kodama's Reach to give you an enormous amount of selection. Your gifts piles frequently included Hana Kami, Soulless Revival, and Eerie Procession (which served as a second copy of Soulless Revival). The idea was that you could then start splicing Soulless Revival onto your various Arcane spells to rebuy Hana Kami over and over again. You'd slowly lock the game out by looping spells like Hideous Laughter, Cranial Extraction, and Ethereal Haze.

Spliced Gifts by Frank Karsten

Gifts in Standard

Ever since watching Frank Karsten crush Worlds in 2005 with it, Greater Gifts has been one of my favorite decks of all time. This deck shares a lot of ideas with the Block Constructed version of the deck. There's still Sakura-Tribe Elder, Farseek, and Kodama's Reach as fixing and acceleration. There's still exactly two unique removal spells. Now there are two unique recursion spells to make Gifts piles easier in Reclaim and Recollect. The key difference between this deck and the Block one is the end game. This time the end game involves sacrificing Kokusho and Yosei to Greater Good over and over again courtesy of Goryo's Vengeance. It's worth noting that this is the deck that first popularized the gameplay pattern of using Gifts as a double Entomb to guarantee that your Kagemaro, Kokusho, or Yosei ended up in the graveyard.

Gifts in Extended

Extended is where some of my favorite Gifts decks of all time have existed. This is the format where the cardpool starts to get deep enough that you can play tons of singletons to get into some really interesting Gifts piles. This is where you'd first see Gifts paired with Life from the Loam and Academy Ruins to loop artifacts like Engineered Explosives or Mindslaver if you were given enough time. It's also where you'd see Gifts paired with Glittering Wish and Living Wish for even more flexibility. This is also where we start seeing cards that want to end up in the graveyard as part of Gifts piles, such as Cabal Therapy and Genesis. 



Gifts in Modern

This is, admittedly, where things start to go a little off the rails. Gifts in Modern is primarily relegated to two things. You are either setting up a storm kill with Past in Flames or setting up an Unburial Rites. The format is too fast and too diverse for anything else to really be worthwhile. That said, that hasn't stopped people from exploring Rock-style decks with Gifts Ungiven featuring the likes of Lingering Souls, Life from the Loam, and retrace spells.

For how linear Gifts frequently is in Modern, this deck shows off the kinds of things I wish were possible. Gifts packages involving Life from the Loam left you start looping utility lands like Ghost Quarter, Gavony Township, and Treetop Village. You can set up Urborg, Tomb of Yawgmoth and Raven's Crime in attrition-heavy matchups. You can do all kinds of crazy Sun Titan tricks in conjunction with Liliana of the Veil and Knight of the Reliquary. Sure, there are some fairly linear choices, but there's also an infinitely complex and interesting puzzle of non-standard piles that include mixes of removal spells, lands, and other key pieces.

Gifts Legacy and Vintage

Here's the thing: Gifts Ungiven doesn't really see play in Legacy and Vintage. There was a time when Gifts was restricted in Vintage, but both formats have really passed it by. Intuition still sees occasional play in Legacy as a way to set up Accumulated Knowledge, Life from the Loam, or Sevinne's Reclamation, but that's about the end of it. To my knowledge, the original Gifts deck in Vintage was Meandeck Gifts - a deck fundamentally built around the pile of Yawgmoth's Will, Tinker, Recoup, and Time Walk. That said, in Vintage you have enough busted singletons that there are all manner of interesting piles involving Ancestral Recall and Yawgmoth's Will or just piles of mana. That flexibility led to a lot of interesting choices until Paradoxical Outcome came around and did all of those things better.

_____________________________________________________________________

Gifts In Commander

So what does this mean for Commander? Gifts is a card with a really interesting legacy that only sees niche play these days. It's banned in Commander for many of the reasons that it's played in Modern. It has the potential to be an instant-speed way to set up a super linear way of either ending the game on the spot or locking your opponent out of the game. 

Gifts Ungiven is unlike any other card on the banned list. It doesn't fit the old 'egregiously expensive' criteria for things like Power. It isn't a permanent that centralizes the rest of the game on itself like Primeval Titan, Sylvan Primordial, or Griselbrand. It's not a busted mana engine like Tolarian Academy. It doesn't immediately bury the table in cards like Yawgmoth's Bargain. It doesn't cheat anything into play like Tinker. It doesn't reset the game. Gifts is a tutor that is only ever as good as the supporting cast. Let's be clear, there are absolutely dozens of Gifts piles across ever possible color combination that will end games. 

Some people choose to push Commander to the limits with cEDH. At higher-power tables, an end step Gifts will probably lead to someone untapping and winning the game. That said, there are plenty of cEDH decks that can easily be ported down for budget decks and lower-power builds. Despite that, I never see Godo or Najeela combo off. I rarely see games won off of Laboratory Maniac. I've never seen a Gitrog Monster deck combo off with state-based effects. If someone wants to do something busted in your games, they already have all the tools they need to do so - the legality of Gifts Ungiven isn't going to fundamentally change that.

If we're going to judge Gifts based on its worst-case scenario, then what about other tutors? Why are they exempt from that criteria? Are we really going to argue that Gifts Ungiven is more efficient or has more unfair applications than the likes of vintage staples like Vampiric Tutor and Demonic Tutor? I have never seen a Tainted Pact or Demonic Consultation cast in the absence of Thassa's Oracle or Laboratory Maniac. Despite that, we still see people casting tutors for lands, silver bullets, and answers in lower-powered games. Fundamentally, people can and do play fair with busted tutors. We've collectively agreed not to judge them based on their most unfair applications, but to let different people play with them in different ways.

People who want to break Gifts are going to break it, there's absolutely no question about that. That said, just slotting Gifts into an existing deck is unlikely to break it. Some people will just get some combination of four haymakers and answers. Still others will do something in between that sets up some kind of value engine. This dichotomy of fair and unfair applications isn't unique to Gifts Ungiven. What is unique is that Gifts Ungiven is banned while every other tutor that has ever been printed (sans Tinker and Primeval Titan) is legal.
TLDR

All I'm trying to say is that it seems odd to me that Gifts Ungiven is the single tutor in the entirety of Magic that crosses the line on power, efficiency, or gameplay concerns. If we can be trusted to play with degenerate engines like Hermit Druid and super efficient tutors like Demonic Tutor without breaking Rule 0, I think we can be trusted to have Gifts Ungiven.

Tuesday, June 9, 2020

Let's Talk About Interaction

It shouldn't be a secret to anyone that I've soured quite a bit on Magic in general and Commander in particular over the last couple of years. Some amount of that is that the game and format are very different than they used to be and I'm getting to a curmudgeon-y age. But I think that some amount of my concerns are real, learnable, and I'm starting to find the words to articulate my dissastisfaction.

Fundamentally, I think my issue is that, more and more frequently, I'm seeing decks fall into one of three categories, all of which can be responsible creating different kinds of non-games:

  • Get ahead, stay ahead
  • Go Bigger
  • Unbreakable Value
Let's break these down briefly.


Get Ahead, Stay Ahead


These are decks that want to get on the board quickly and generate an overwhelming advantage early in the game. Think Commanders like Winota, Krenko, Animar, and Najeela. These frequently let you cheat on mana to cast more spells than your opponents early in the game and generate an insurmountable advantage if you aren't interacted with early and often.


Go Bigger

These are decks that largely want to ignore their opponent and play a bunch of set up spells. Usually ramp spells, mana rocks, and then a few key 'combo' pieces that let you leverage that mana into an enormous advantage. I think about commanders like Wort, the Raidmother, Kinnan, and Zacama, which can be primarily  composed of ramp spells and payoffs. If they have time to execute their plans, you're going to get absolutely buried in mana advantage or just get 'combo killed' because they can play multiple haymakers in a turn.

Unbreakable Value

These are decks that try to set up an unbreakable board full of small moving pieces that give you built in protection, redundancy, and resiliency. I think of aristocrat commanders like Athreos, Teshar, and Gerard that try to build up an engine that slowly accrues more and more value and becomes increasingly difficult to break apart. Think about sacrifice outlets and recursion and Blood Arists and Grave Pacts that slowly lock opponents out of different aspects of the game, become increasingly resilient to creature and graveyard interaction, and slowly draw more cards and drain more life turn after turn.

Why Does This Matter?

I want to be clear - there's nothing fundamentally wrong with pursuing these kinds of strategies - many of my decks fall into these broad generalizations. The issue is that the pool of powerful, linear, and proactive cards is so much bigger now than it used to be. Decks are becoming increasingly streamlined with more mana acceleration, more redundancy, and more explosive potential.

Explosive decks have more two-mana rocks than ever before and cheap protection than ever before, and those cards are creeping into more and more decklists. The Go Big decks have a higher density of efficient ramp spells and an increasingly broad selection of powerful, synergistic payoffs. The value engine decks have more copies of Selfless Spirit, Grave Pact, and Scrap Trawler-esque effects.

As all of these decks become leaner and more focused, I'm seeing a higher proportion of non-games where one person gets to do their thing hard enough that the rest of the table is irrelevant. Frequently, that person will sort of shrug at the end of the game and say something to the effect of 'I thought people would have more interaction.'

But here's a thing that I'm noticing - when I get asked to look at decks, there's less and less interactive cards across the board. People are trimming on interaction to make space for more redundancy, more acceleration, more exciting and shiny proactive cards. The issue is that, when everyone does this, no one has the interaction that everyone else is expecting to keep them in check. That leas to more games quickly spiral out of control.

Some groups might be totally fine with that style of game - and that's completely fine! Personally, I think the fun part of the game is the midgame, where there's tension and posturing and politicking, in favor of games where the players could just as well be playing in separate rooms.

What Next?

I guess my recommendation is that people think about what kind of game they want to play and then take a look at how much and what types of interactive elements exist in their decks, as well as how compact, resilient, and redundant their core gameplan is. Does that combination contribute to the kind of games you and your friends enjoy?

Does your deck depend on combat or not? How many axes can your core gameplan be interacted on (e.g. counterspells, graveyard hate, artifact destruction, etc)? How much of your deck is dedicated to executing your own plan versus engaging with your opponents in a meaningful way? How quickly can you execute that plan and how much counterplay is available once you do? 

I did this exercise with the four decks that I had closest on hand, and I was honestly pretty surprised at the results.

Breaking My Decks Down

The four decks I had on hand were my Raff Capashen Superfriends deck, Teshar Midrange, Ephara Midrange, and Kemba Midrange.

I was shocked to find that Kemba had six total pieces of interaction, and that's if you count Karmic Justice, which is definitely a stretch. Raff played 17 pieces of interaction, but those were largely sweepers. That makes a clear statement that I really just want to ignore what everyone else is doing until I can execute my own plan rather than engaging with theirs in a meaningful way. Teshar dedicates fully twice as many cards to protecting my board rather than engaging with opponents. 

Ephara had the most interaction with a full 10 spot removal spells plus graveyard hate and sweepers - a full fifth of the deck is interactive cards. But here's the kicker: that hasn't felt like enough in those games. How much of that is that my balance is wrong? I don't know. But it's also possible that other decks at the table have been making the same decisions I have - cutting down on removal in the name of making space for more shiny proactive pieces.

Wrapping Up

So what's the point? Is it wrong for people to enjoy games where you just see who can execute their plan the fastest? Absolutely not. Games where people largely ignore each other and race to do busted stuff are part of Magic and some people live for it. It's not for me.

I want games where there's a push and pull and where most players get a chance to try to meaningfully execute their plan before someone runs away with it. A core part of those games is that everyone contributes interaction to help keep the game relatively stable while we all scramble to try to do our thing. A cursory review of my decks shows that, even though I enjoy that kind of game, I haven't been building my decks in a way that's consistent with that approach.

It's getting easier and easier to fall into the trap of packing your deck full of nothing but efficient, proactive, powerful cards. So I encourage everyone to take a few minutes to reflect on what kinds of games you've enjoyed the most - is it super compact? Battle cruiser? Midrangey? Politicky? Once you have that answer, honestly ask whether you're building decks that contribute to that style of game or not.