The last two weeks or so has been one of those periods where I dive back into the format. One thing that I can't overstate is how different the format is - largely unrecognizeable from what it used to be, at least from my perspective. In and of itself, that's neither good nor bad. I just worry that changes by degrees are harder to notice if you're saturated in the format, and wonder at what point a conversation needs to be had about what the format's identity is supposed to be. What does "healthy" mean, where's the line on power, and what are the things that are constraining the format?
So what is this supposed to be. It's a writeup that no one asked for about what the current format, post initiative, feels like to someone who has played a lot historically, but is relatively new to the current iteration of things.
To what end? I don't really know. I'm no one, and there's no reason for anyone to take these thoughts seriously. I think it's mostly just me getting some thoughts off of my desk, so to speak, but maybe there's something useful in my ramblings.
Monarch and Initiative
The new excitement. I, personally, have never been a fan of the monarch as a mechanic is two-player formats. That said, I don't think that monarch was ever toxic to the point of needing action taken against it. Sure, it encouraged some play patterns where you turtle up with Palace Sentinels and Prismatic Strands, but the format was trending in that direction anyway given how efficient and varied the aggressive decks have become.
However, I think things are different with initiative. I honestly don't know that these things are really over the line on power. The thing is, we've hit a density of four-mana effects that make non-interactable emblems that enables people to play Dark Ritual and Lotus Petal to power them out as early as possible. I think this creates a lot of perverse incentives and toxic play patterns. Honest, fair decks will struggle to exist in a format where this is part of the baseline. I think this is likely to push the format even further into decks that are either piles of rate and/or trying to be as non-interactive as possible.
The one upside I see to initiative is that it gives all these Ephemerate and Ghostly Flicker decks a way to actually end the game in a timely fashion. Fundamentally though, I think the density of these effects and the way their existence constrains the rest of the format begs a question: are these going to be the identity of the format moving forward?
Free Spells
Pauper has storied history of free spells eventually hitting a point where they are unhealthy. Frantic Search, Invigorate, Cloud of Faeries, Gush, Daze, and Gitaxian Probe are all examples of cards that are wildly powerful relative to the rest of the format. Given what the format looks like today, there's a new batch of free cards for which I have to ask - are these still contributing to play patterns that are fun or healthy?
Let's start with Mutagenic Growth and Manamorphose. These are the cards that are currently powering the Mono-Red Kiln Fiend decks. These free spells, combined with the high density of pseudo-Prowess creatures and Temur Battle Rage, are consistently capable of killing players on turn three and four through interaction.
Invigorate and Gitaxian Probe were already banned for enablings things like this, and I just don't feel like Mutagenic Growth and Manamorphose are that different anymore. We already hit the point years ago that control decks leaned on Stonehorn Dignitary and Fog over removal spells because of how efficienct and diverse the threats in Pauper are. Now we've hit a point where you can consistently die before Stonehorn is even castable.
Fundamentally, the existence of a deck this consistently fast is an enormous constraint on what kinds of decks are playable, and forces the format down to the decks with the most efficient interaction. There is no going over the top because there is no time.
Last, let's briefly talk about Lotus Petal. Traditionally, Lotus Petal shows up in decks that are up to no good. These have typically been combo decks that fluctuate between powerful, but fragile and format-defining based on the availalbe payoffs. In the current format, that's not really true anymore. Thanks to initiative, we're now starting to see fair decks use Lotus Petal as a way to get a turn faster - to sneak haymakers under Counterspell or get out ahead of Kiln Fiend. Honestly, given the blistering speed of games, I also think it's worth considering whether the only reason we haven't seen more experimentation with Lotus Petal is because of its price online.
None of these cards are generally in decks where people are trying to do something fair. And all of them are likely to continue showing up in increasingly problematic decks in the future.
The Rest
To be clear, I don't necessarily believe that any of the things outlined above are necessarily overbearing in terms of raw power or metagame portion. That said, I think Monarch, Initiative, and free spells ask a core question about what the format's identity is supposed to be. These are the things that serious constraints on what kinds of decks can be played because of the specificity of their demands and the severity of the consequences for failing to meet them. If you can't interact with or overpower them early, your deck is not playable.
Personally, I don't like these constraints and I'd be interested to see what the format looks like without these format-defining pressures before considering serious action on anything else. Right now, games feel like they center around turns two through four. What happens if there's more space to go over the top? Are there Fangren Marauder or cascade decks that can overpower the current status quo, but are boxed out by Kiln Fiends and turbo emblems?
The alternative is setting a new baseline for acceptable power, at which point I think we should probably consider whether cards can be unbanned now that standards have changed. Realistically though, the overwhelming majority of the banned list is dedicated to things that are traditionally unfair (free spells, storm) or decks that are still overbearingly powerful today (affinity, blue tempo). What does that leave? I guess Cloudpost, Bonder's Ornament, and Prophetic Prism? I'm not sure those cards make anything better, but Cloudpost can't be worth the risk.
Regardless, it feels like the format is at a crossroads of sorts, and a decision needs to be made about what it's going to be. Is it a format that soft rotates as s high powered cards and mechanics are printed directly into the format? Are we going to do anything about the archetypes and shells that consistently make the best use all of the new toys? Is there a general philosophy on what a "healthy" format looks like or at what point a card, archetype, or mechanic is too format warping or toxic? Does that change if something is analagous to something that's already been banned for enabling similar problems or play patterns?
Personally, I'd want to go nuclear. Kill the cards that put harsh constraints on the format, knock the piles of raw rate down that have sat at the top of the metagame down a peg, and try to bring back a world where honest decks are playable. Would it fix anything? I have no idea.
One thing I know for sure is that I don't envy the people who have to answer these questions, because people are going to be mad no matter what. As for me, I'm just going to comfortably settle into my role of playing boomer decks that have become wildly outclassed.
No comments:
Post a Comment