Saturday, March 7, 2020

Common Commander

One of my least favorite things about Commander is how pricey so many of the core cards have become. I've already got a substantive collection, so I can usually cannibalize one or more existing projects rather than dropping a few hundred dollars on a new deck. That's an enormous privilege that I have because I've been playing for multiple decades.

There's an incredible amount of great budget commander content is a testament to how dedicated the community is to ensuring that anyone can play, regardless of their budget. That said, decks that I built on a tight budget 10 years ago are now worth several hundred dollars purely because of cards that haven't been reprinted at the same pace that Commander demand has grown.

One of my favorite budget projects from back in the day was a Pauper Commander deck - the Commander of your choice backed up by nothing but commons. It was honestly an interesting challenge back in 2010ish and I was actually able to build a very reasonable Child of Alara deck that could reasonably keep pace with most casual tables. I thought it would be interesting to revisit that project and see how budget friendly it was in 2020.

After looking at my old list and making some updates for sets that have come out since I last updated it, this is where I ended up. There's four key categories of cards in this deck. Let's briefly break them down.

Acceleration and Fixing

This is absolutely key. Playing a 5-Color deck without the best dual lands and mana rocks is not an easy feat. Cards like Kodama's Reach and Cultivate are superstars. Mycosynth Wellspring and Darksteel Ingot are critical early fixing. Farhaven Elf even plays really well with all the powerful recursion and flicker effects. Perhaps the most important ramp spell in the entire deck is Far Wanderings. Three lands for one card is a stellar way of setting up the powerful recursion loops that this deck relies on.

Card Advantage

Pound for pound, the cards in this deck are substantially worse than the average Commander deck. That's especially true now that so many Commanders are busted value engines unto themselves. With that in mind, you've got to be able to generate enough value to keep up with a table's worth of opponents. Cards like Secrets of the Golden City and Treasure Cruise are key to ensuring that you can keep up.

That said, the real plan here is the combination of buyback spells, creatures that buyback spells like Archaeomancer, and recursion spells like Grim Harvest, Capsize, and Ghostly Flicker. These varied recursion engines team up with your limited suite of targeted answers to ensure that you can keep the board relatively stable.

The Child Engine

In general, your gameplan is to use spot removal to keep the board at parity. Sometimes that won't be possible - someone will have gotten too far ahead. That's what Child is for. The gameplan here is to find various ways to sacrifice Child for value over and over again. The best version of this effect is Mind Extraction, which sweeps the board and discards your opponent's hand. The other exciting ones are Perilous Research and Altar's Reap, both of which let you kill Child at instant-speed. Sidisi's Faithful may seem out of place in a value-oriented deck like this, but you can stack triggers such that Sidisi's Faithful bounces itself before Child's trigger resolves.

The other half of the engine is the myriad of ways to rebuy Child and ensure that you can sweep the board all over again if things get out of hand. From Mortuary Mire plus bouncelands to Grim Harest and Disturbed Burial, you've got all manner of ways to ensure that you don't run out of ways to keep Child on the board.

The Combo Finish

There's lots of ways to try to end the game with this deck depending on how you want to construct it. This build opts to combine Ghostly Flicker, Cloud of Faeries, a Mnemonic Wall effect, and multiple bouncelands to generate infinite mana for Rolling Thunder. Other options include things like Lifespark Spellbomb and Freed from the Real, flickering Dinrova Horror over and over again, or even just beating down with Child of Alara.

But What About Budget?

Now that you know what the deck is trying to do, let's take a look at how budget-friendly it is. The build that I'd throw together out of my collection comes in at about $100. In the overall scheme of things that's not terrible - but it is awfully pricey for a deck full of commons, especially when I was able to build it for about $30 back in 2010. This isn't even including the possibility of playing Snow basics and Skred as another efficient removal spell - that alone is going to add another $15-20 to the cost of the deck.

A lot of the price is in just a handful of cards that have increased in demand without any kind of reprint. Things like Rhystic Study, Merchant Scroll, Preordain, and Path of Ancestry are pretty hefty chunk of the value of this deck. But are these budget-breakers critical to how the deck functions? Not especially. Here's some recommendations for taking this and bringing the price more in line with what you might expect for a pile of commons.
  • Cloud of Faeries → Peregrine Drake or another piece of a combo finish. 
  • Sakura-Tribe Elder → Rampant Growth
  • Farhaven Elf → Ondu Giant
  • Expedition Map → Reap and Sow
  • Wayfarer's Bauble → Font of Fertility / Embodiment of Spring
  • Trinket Mage → Vedalken Aethermage
  • Rhystic Study → Read the Bones
  • Counterspell → Arcane Denial
  • Muddle the Mixture → Deprive
  • Preordain → Portent
  • Merchant Scroll → Brainspoil
  • Kodama's Reach → Grow from the Ashes
  • Primal Growth → Deep Reconnaissance
  • Path of Ancestry → Cave of Temptation
This is just an example of how you can find cards that fill similar functionalities to bring down the price of the deck. There are plenty of cards in your piles of draft commons that fill similar roles and let you play with favorites from Limited formats past. Is the deck better if you can play more of the few tutors that have been printed at common? Absolutely. But they aren't necessary if you're more concerned about budget than theme. These changes bring the price of the deck down to right around $40, and there's still plenty of cards in the $1-2 range that you could swap out for other things if you were so inclined.

The pieces here are fairly generic - you'd like to play the most efficient or most flexible version of the various counterspells, ramp spells, and recursion effects. But if you want to bring the price down or just don't have access to them, then just replace them with something more affordable. Is Ghostly Flicker better than Displace? Sure - but only because it can occasionally blink lands. Counterspell is certainly better than Cancel or Arcane Denial, but you can absolutely get by with budget options, metagame calls, or even just ones that bring back good memories from old formats.

Cards like Pyroblast and Hydroblast are great ways to kill your Child of Alara or target key players in your local metagame. You could absolutely add more cards like Forsake the Worldly or Rend Flesh. Look through your collection for cards that fill the roles that the deck needs, supplement with powerful commons that are in your budget. There's no end to hyper-specific, powerful answers like Ancient Grudge and Ray of Revelation, even in Pauper. You don't even have to stick to commons - Blood for Bones and Rescue from the Underworld are great sacrifice outlets. You can go even bigger with Momentous Fall or Morbid Curiosity.

The moral of the story is that you don't have to break your budget to build a deck that does powerful things. Find a powerful effect, back it up with card advantage, answers, and the best ramp you can find, and you'll be just fine.

No comments:

Post a Comment