Monday, May 25, 2020

My Tireless Quest

There is no commander that has been more frustrating to me since it's printing than Golos. This card does everything that I want a Commander to do - it ramps you a non-basic land and encourages you to play expensive, five-color nonsense - so why am I struggling with it so much?


This fall, I built my first take on Golos. I even wrote about it. That deck had two goals. First, combine Golos and flicker effects, especially repeatable ones like Nim Deathmantle and Eldrazi Displacer to assemble crazy combinations of utility lands. Second, make many copies of Field of the Dead and bury the table in zombies.

That deck was very good, very consistent, and incredibly resilient. Frequently a single ramp spell meant you started making two zombies per land drop on the fifth turn of the game, and it only ramped up from there. Each flicker effect was more zombies, and even if your opponents had sweepers you could stock up on fetchlands or just recast your Commander and a flicker and suddenly you've got twelve Zombies again. It quickly becomes super overbearing presence at the table because it's incredibly difficult for opponents to actually break your board and buy themselves a turn to breathe and counterattack.

I got comments from my friends that it needed to be toned back. Way back. Some going as far as saying that it wasn't possible for a Golos deck to be casual. I tried cutting back on repeatable flickers. I tried cutting back on extra land drops. It still did the same thing, and I had to face the truth: the problem is Thespian's Stage and Vesuva. Sure, Parallel Lives and company are probably more unfair than extra copies of Field of the Dead in the absolute sense. But my Commander all but guarantees that I'll have three copies of Field of the Dead by turn six or seven every single game. The consistency and resiliency provided by that was the fundamental problem.

So if I have to change the foundational goal of my deck, where do we go from here? Just jamming your deck full of expensive haymakers like Praetors and Eldrazi is not my thing, and that feels like it also has the potential to feel overbearing at the table. I have an Emeria, the Sky Ruin deck, and building around Valakut in this shell feels even less fun that Field of the Dead.

What's in Your Head?

Introspection time. Setting aside the obvious land shenanigans, what is it about Field of the Dead that I enjoy so much? Realistically, I like the resiliency. I enjoy grinding in my games, so the core experience I'm looking for is slowly building up an overwhelming mass of zombies while The Cranberries play on repeat in my head.

Okay. That's something to work with. So what if I just played with one Field of the Dead? There are plenty of other, non-land ways to make more zombie tokens to keep the feeling the same while lowering the power level. I could even add more cards that lean into the zombie token theme instead of the generically powerful cards. What if we made Golos a Zombie tribal deck where Field of the Dead makes you less sad about sweepers?

I had recently taken apart a Gisa and Geralf deck, and promptly started digging through my collection to find those pieces. I ended up swapping up about twenty non-land cards - fully half of the ones in the deck - to end up with something that is hopefully both very similar and very different to what I had before. Here's the things that made the cut:

  1. Gravespawn Sovereign
  2. Genesis
  3. Corpse Connoisseur
  4. Death Baron
  5. Dark Impostor
  6. Josu Vess, Lich Knight
  7. Noosegraf Mob
  8. Vindictive Lich
  9. Grave Titan
  10. Soul of Innistrad
  11. Vizier of Many Faces
  12. Rot Hulk
  13. Liliana, Untouched by Death
  14. Ever After
  15. Dread Return
  16. Silence the Believers
  17. Rescue from the Underworld
  18. Buried Alive
The core idea here was to add a core Zombie package of Grave Titan, Gravespawn Sovereign, Noosegraf Mob, and Rot Hulk. These cards play well with one another, as all the zombies team up with Gravespawn Sovereign and sacrifice outlets to ensure that your zombie presence continues to grow. They also generally play well with flickers to still generate a board presence that's difficult to break up, but in a way that's easier for opponents to interact with and harder for me to assemble.

In addition to that, we've got some cool ways to play out of the graveyard. I'm not sure that Genesis is necessary, but I love Buried Alive and Corpse Connoisseur as ways to set up the graveyard for Ever After and Liliana, Untouched by Death. I also love Soul of Innistrad, Vizier of Many Faces, and Liliana, Untouched by Death giving you pseudo-flashback creatures.


Josu Vess is an interesting choice. I picked it over Army of the Damned because it's a creature. That said, the only ways to rebuy it are Soul of Innistrad and Genesis, so maybe it either needs more support or isn't worthwhile. I don't want that to be a card like Empty the Pits, which is a little too easy to pair with Cabal Coffers to just end the game on someone's end step out of nowhere.

We've also got Silence the Believers and Dark Impostor as mana sinks for Cabal Coffers. If we're going to try to cast giant zombies and still be activating Golos, we're going to need to focus more on Coffers plus Urborg - it's probably even worthwhile to find space for Cabal Stronghold and potentially Nykthos as backup.

The Aftermath

I've gotten two games in with this deck since I rebuilt it, and I think I'm much happier with it. You still do Zombie things - Noosegraf mob is an absolute joy to play with - but you have to work much harder to do them, which is roughly what I was looking for. You have to make difficult choices between casting your spells, activating Golos, or leaving up lands to do things like pay for Nim Deathmantle or Gavony Township.

There are still some things to worry about - the potential to loop Vindictive Lich a few times with Nim Deathmantle or Soul of Innistrad to just kill someone from a high life total, for example. Generally speaking though, I'm much happier with the Zombie list than I was with the Field of the Dead list. There's still a couple interesting questions that I want to work on, but those are for future me:

  1. I played a 15+ turn game yesterday where I still had a hand full of lands at the end of the game. Are cards that allow multiple land drops more acceptable now that there are fewer Field triggers?
  2. Is it worthwhile to try to build around looping hideaway lands with karoos as a way to dig for more zombie spells and give the deck more instant-speed ways to do things?
  3. Pseudo-lords like Gleaming Overseer, Aven Wind Guide, Risen Executioner, Eternal Skylord, and Necromancer's Covenant are almost certainly worth considering.
  4. Varina, Lich Queen? Is this a reasonable way to turn lands into gas and/or stock the graveyard? The deck doesn't have a ton of non-creature recursion anymore, so I'm not sure if looting is what I want or not.
  5. How good is Endless Ranks of the Dead? It rarely made it around the table in my previous Zombie builds, but maybe it's worth trying again.




No comments:

Post a Comment