Monday, October 7, 2019

Fundamental Flaws

Have you ever had an idea that seemed like a lot of fun but didn't live up to your expectations? Some off-the-wall idea that seems like it'd lead to whacky games and laughs that just never came together in gameplay? I've never had anything go as catastrophically wrong as my Vorel of the Hull Clade build. I'm not breaking it up just yet - just putting it on indefinite hiatus - but the process of building and playing the deck taught me a lot about how Commander has changed since I first started playing around Conflux.


The idea behind Vorel was simple. Everyone using Vorel to do fun tricks with +1/+1 counters; wouldn't it be cool if I built around charge counters instead? With that simple vision in mind, I set out to find the coolest engines built around charge counters that I could find, starting with big mana.


It turns out there are plenty of cute cards that care about charge counters that can start getting out of hand given enough time:
  • Everflowing Chalice
  • Astral Cornucopia
  • Druid's Repository
  • Pentad Prism
  • City of Shadows
  • Empowered Autogenerator
  • Mage-Ring Network
  • Gyre Sage
  • Workhorse

Cards like these are the backbone of the deck. This deck really wants to be casting enormous artifacts and activating Vorel multiple times per turn cycle. That means that you need a ton of mana, and this is how you do it. Combine these with proliferate effects, Surge Node, Coretapper, and more, and you've got the potential to be cranking out huge sums of mana. But what do you do with it all? The obvious and most important answer is to sink your mana into X spells that draw cards so that you can find payoffs, keep hitting land drops, and find more engine pieces. That said, it turns out there are a number of interesting things that you can do once you've got charge counters flowing and a bunch of mana available:
  • Titan Forge
  • Ring of Three Wishes
  • Transmogrifying Wand
  • Umezawa's Jitte
  • Golem Foundry
  • Shrine of Burning Range
  • Shrine of Loyal Legions
  • Shrine of Limitless Power
  • Magistrate's Scepter
  • Lux Cannon
All of these add up to some interesting engines with high potential. At some point, you can have enough mana to generate enough counters each turn that cards like Lux Cannon are self-sustaining and you can afford to activate Ring of Three Wishes to find and cast whatever card you need for the situation.


And that's it. That's the deck idea. Add in some cantrips and tutors for consistency, Academy Ruins for recursion, and a couple of interactive spells to make sure we can shut off Stony Silences and the like, and we should be good, right?

Have you spotted the problem yet? I played five games with this deck and never came close to doing anything relevant. In each game, I'd spend the first five-ish turns finding a charge counter mana rock and getting it spun up to somewhere between four and eight mana. Then in every single one of those games, my engine got broken up, either by a Disenchant because someone was afraid of what I'd do with a ton of mana, or by a sweeper that incidentally hits all of the mana rocks on the board.

The problem with this deck is that artifacts are inherently fragile, and aren't really dependable. This is particularly as more and more people are playing larger quantities of efficient mana rocks because there becomes an increasing incentive to be able to interact with artifacts early and often.

If I really wanted to try to make this work, it'd involve two big changes. First, the deck would need far more countermagic to protect itself from artifact destruction. Second, the deck would probably need to be rebuilt to focus on land-based ramp spells as a more solid foundation on which to start doing silly charge counter things.


  1. That said, I don't really want to do that - what I really want to focus in on is the lessons I learned from this: Games of Commander are much faster and higher power than what I'm used to. Everyone is building a Rube Goldberg machine, but much faster than before. Commander products have introduced a lot of "get ahead, stay ahead" mechanics that I'm not a fan of. Games are much more likely to pivot on key spot removal and counterspells early on in the game than they were before. There are times you won't get to your sweeper, or by the time you can cast it someone has turned their board advantage into so many cards that it just doesn't matter.
  2. You can't build decks around things that everyone else is taking advantage of and try to do the same thing but slower. This deck's problem is that the first step involves investing multiple turns into getting your artifacts online. Step two assumes that those artifacts live for multiple turns to pay for everything else. In a world where everyone is playing a billion mana rocks, you can't expect your artifacts to be safe, which means that you frequently never get to step two.

I don't think that there's a lot of value in arguing about whether or not commander is "better" now that we've started to see cards designed for the format. I would argue that it's gotten a lot more homogeneous, but that's not necessarily a measure of "goodness." What's important to recognize is that the format has fundamentally changed. Even outside of CEDH, decks have shifted from being slow, ponderous battle cruisers to lean, efficient machines. In recent months I've seen relatively casual decks kill tables on turns 4-6.

The format is faster and more powerful than it was when I played the most. That's not necessarily good or bad - just different - but it's certainly something that you need to keep at the forefront of your thoughts as you start exploring your next crazy idea.


No comments:

Post a Comment